Best Bacon Menu Item on Long Island

Who doesn’t love bacon? It goes great with anything: sandwiches, omelettes, pizza, chicken…even ice cream (nice one, Burger King). This greasy, crispy food has become a staple in restaurant dishes across the country, and Long Island joints have mastered its use. So go ahead, indulge in what’s probably the best piece of grub to ever…

Best Chocolatier on Long Island

Unless you’re allergic to chocolate, you probably love it (or you’re just not human). There possibly couldn’t be anything better than it — unless it’s handmade by a local chocolatier, that is. Chocolatiers put a spin on this delicious treat by molding and forming it into anything they can imagine. Cream-filled balls, small statues and…

Best Rice Pudding on Long Island

There’s nothing like a delicious rice pudding. They all seem to be unique and have their own story. Rice pudding can be sweet or creamy or both! Eat it with a hint of cinnamon or with raisins inside, whatever you prefer! Craving this delicious dessert yet? 2025: Long Islanders Voted Lucky Lou’s Gourmet Pudding Best…

Best Smoothie on Long Island

Smoothies are a great way to get your daily suggested servings of fruits and vegetables. They’re especially good in the summer because they help you stay cool in addition to healthy. Smoothie joints have popped up all over Long Island in the past few years, serving up delicious variations of this fruity drink. Some are…

Best Potato Chips on Long Island

Crunchy, salty, and downright addictive, potato chips are a snack-time favorite that never goes out of style. Whether you love them classic and lightly salted, thick-cut and kettle-cooked, or boldly flavored with unique seasonings, the best potato chips are all about the perfect crunch and taste. Long Island is home to spots that craft some…

Best Ice Cream on Long Island

Long Islanders always scream for ice cream! Perhaps the most delicious member of the dairy family, you can never go wrong with a banana split or a hot fudge sundae, even on a Tuesday. Ice cream just seems to bring smiles to people’s faces, more the reason to eat it as often as possible. So…

Best Lobster Roll on Long Island

Some big food chains have introduced lobster rolls to their menus, but there’s nothing quite like one from a local Long Island restaurant. Lobster meat soaked in butter and served on a steamed hotdog bun makes the perfect lunch or dinner on the way home from the beach over the summer. And with so many…

Best Shrimp Scampi on Long Island

Calling all garlic lovers! The quest for Long Island’s most delectable shrimp scampi is over, and the winner basks in garlicky glory! Chosen by your fellow seafood enthusiasts, this years winner for Best Shrimp Scampi on Long Island will not disappoint. 2025: Long Islanders Voted Gallery Four Italian Restaurant Best Shrimp Scampi! Gallery Four Italian…

Best Soft Pretzel on Long Island

Pretzels are good just the way they are, but they’re even better in the form of a big, warm and soft one. They’re not as salty, nor are they crunchy, so they definitely fall under that comfort food category Long Islanders all know and love. Soft pretzels are great served with mustard or cheese, or…

Best BLT on Long Island

Crispy bacon, fresh lettuce, and juicy tomato layered between toasted bread—there’s a reason the BLT is a timeless favorite. Simple yet satisfying, a well-made BLT is all about using the freshest ingredients and just the right balance of flavors. Long Island is home to countless delis and diners putting their own twist on this classic…