Best Milkshake on Long Island

Strawberry, chocolate, vanilla! Flavors galore! A classic milkshake can be enjoyed all-year round whether you dip it in fries or enjoy it as a refreshing summer dessert. Revel in deliciousness while indulging your sweet tooth with the best milkshake on Long Island. 2025: Long Islanders Voted Douglas & James Homemade Ice Cream (Sweat Treats on…

Best Calamari on Long Island

Ahh, fried squid. Sounds appetizing, yeah? If not, then how does calamari sound? Much better, we’re assuming. This dish, most commonly found at Italian restaurants, is a must-have on Long Island if you’re venturing out for seafood on a summer evening. Served best with marinara sauce, aioli, or even just plain, calamari is golden, crispy…

Best Grilled Cheese on Long Island

Perfectly melted cheese—grilled cheese is the ultimate comfort food. Whether you love the simplicity of a classic American cheese melt or prefer a gourmet twist with artisan cheeses, savory add-ons, and specialty breads, the perfect grilled cheese is always warm, gooey, and satisfying. Long Island is home to many spots serving up this timeless favorite,…

Best Spinach Pie on Long Island

People are weird when it comes to spinach. Most dislike it on its own, but when paired with cheese and crust in the form of a pie, they love it. And Long Islanders are no different. Although this food can’t be found at every restaurant on the island, the ones that do serve it do…

Best Fish Market on Long Island

Being that Long Island is surrounded by water, the fish are certainly plenty…not to mention delicious. The island has many different great fish markets thanks to its waterfront cities and hamlets, selling everything from salmon and halibut to trout and tilapia. For only the best in seafood this year, look no further than the Best…

Best Soup on Long Island

There’s nothing better on a chilly fall or winter Long Island afternoon than a hot cup or bowl of soup. Tasty and satisfying, soup is great paired with salad and a piece of bread for dipping, or just on its own. From chicken noodle, to black bean, to Italian Wedding, there are so many different…

Best Wine Shop on Long Island

Whether you’re heading on a picnic, hosting a dinner party, or decompressing at home after a long day, wine is the perfect companion for a good time. A great wine shop offers the finest selections from the vine and knowledgeable aficionados who will steer you toward the perfect purchase. So get a few glasses ready…

Best Butcher on Long Island

These butchers feature the finest selections of meats, from lamb, beef, chicken and other delectable and juicy fleshy sinews. It’s been said that good butchers hide the worst chefs, therefore transforming a typical meal into spectacular feasts! 2025: Long Islanders Voted Scott’s Five Star Meat Center Best Butcher! Scott’s Five Star Meat Center 1155 Jericho…