Best Lobster Roll on Long Island

Some big food chains have introduced lobster rolls to their menus, but there’s nothing quite like one from a local Long Island restaurant. Lobster meat soaked in butter and served on a steamed hotdog bun makes the perfect lunch or dinner on the way home from the beach over the summer. And with so many…

Best Homemade Pasta on Long Island

There’s nothing like homemade pasta that truly satisfies the stomach and the taste buds. With easy-to-make ingredients that are immediately accessible from your pantry at home, supermarket or even at a restaurant if you desire to dine out, you won’t regret your decision. For a superb homemade pasta dish, dine on the best the island…

Best Shrimp Scampi on Long Island

Calling all garlic lovers! The quest for Long Island’s most delectable shrimp scampi is over, and the winner basks in garlicky glory! Chosen by your fellow seafood enthusiasts, this years winner for Best Shrimp Scampi on Long Island will not disappoint. 2024: Long Island Voted Gallery Four Italian Restaurant Best Shrimp Scampi! Gallery Four Italian…

Best Doughnuts on Long Island

2024: Long Island Voted North Fork Doughnut Company Best Doughnuts! North Fork Doughnut Company 5 East Main St, Bay Shore (631) 298-7941 – nofodoco.com Indulge in a delectable array of donuts, ranging from chocolate frosted to jelly-filled and unique blends at North Fork Doughnut Company on Long Island. Satisfying every donut aficionado’s craving, this bakery…

Best BLT on Long Island

Long Island has some great spots for BLTs. The locals have weighed in. See who was voted Best BLT on Long Island. 2024: Long Island Voted Lindenhurst Diner Best BLT! Lindenhurst Diner 195 E Montauk Highway, Lindenhurst (631) 991-8600 – lindenhurstdiner.com Lindenhurst Diner is a staple in the community and well-known for its delicious diner…

Best Soft Pretzel on Long Island

Pretzels are good just the way they are, but they’re even better in the form of a big, warm and soft one. They’re not as salty, nor are they crunchy, so they definitely fall under that comfort food category Long Islanders all know and love. Soft pretzels are great served with mustard or cheese, or…

Best Nachos on Long Island

Nachos are like tortilla chips and salsa, except swap out the salsa and replace it with cheese sauce. And that makes it all the more better. On Long Island, you can get your nachos however you like: plain, topped with a little pico de gallo, or loaded with jalapeños, beef and more for the ultimate…

Best Appetizer on Long Island

What’s an incredible meal at a restaurant without an appetizer to start it off? Mozzarella sticks, potato skins, calamari, quesadillas…okay, we’ll stop. Your mouth is probably watering right now, anyway. Long Island restaurants have so many different varieties of this ‘appetizing’ dish that it was almost impossible to narrow it down to one, but a…

Best Lunch Deal on Long Island

Eating out for lunch really shouldn’t be expensive (that’s what going out to dinner is for). Instead, lunch should be known for great deals and combos to get Long Islanders the most grub for their buck. A simple sandwich, drink and side are pretty much all that are needed for a good, satisfying lunch, but…

Best Burrito on Long Island

2024: Long Islanders Voted Fat Boy’s Burrito Co. Best Burrito! Fat Boy’s Burrito Co. 2496 Merrick Road Bellmore (516) 654-9162 – fatboysburritoco.com In Bellmore, Fat Boy’s Burrito Co. boasts a diverse menu featuring mouthwatering burritos that cater to various tastes. Among their standout creations are the #1 Fat Fish, a beer-battered crispy cod masterpiece with…