Long Island has ideal terrain for all kinds of sports. Couple that with an amazing array of indoor facilities and you’ve got a population who loves to play! Shop our best sporting good store pick to get everything you need to enjoy your favorite sports.
2024: Long Island Voted Hunters Essentials Inc. Best Sporting Goods Store!
Hunters Essentials Inc.
900 Willis Avenue, Albertson
(516) 741-5243 – huntersessentials.com
Supplying handguns, rifles, shotguns, ammo, magazines, optics, knives, parts and gear; Hunters Essentials has everything for your hunting needs, and their website allows you to search by all major manufacturers with most major brands available to purchase your supplies from. Aside from weapons, the store also sells hunting attire, survival supplies, stun guns, scent covers, and decoys as well as books, shoes, trail cameras, bi-pods and tri-pods, cleaning equipment, and cases. Located in Albertson, Hunters Essentials Inc. offers products at reasonable prices, and the staff of professionals are available to answer questions. The store’s website makes shopping online easy, and it is open six days a week, from Monday to Saturday.
2023: Long Islanders Voted Hunters Essentials Inc. Best Sporting Goods Store!
Hunters Essentials Inc.
900 Willis Ave, Albertson
(516) 741-5243 – huntersessentials.com
Hunters Essentials Inc. is a go-to location for hunters, gun enthusiasts, or crossbow users. From shotguns to glocks to rifles, pistols, and other types of handguns, Hunters Essentials Inc. also offers an impressive range of knives, ammunition, holsters, targets, and cases. Aside from weapons, the store also sells hunting attire, survival supplies, stun guns, scent covers, and decoys as well as books, shoes, trail cameras, bi-pods and tri-pods, cleaning equipment, and cases. Located in Albertson, Hunters Essentials Inc. offers products at reasonable prices, and the staff of professionals are available to answer questions. The store’s website makes shopping online easy, and it is open six days a week, from Monday to Saturday.
2022: Long Islanders Voted South Shore Sportsman Best Sporting Goods Store!
South Shore Sportsman
9 Lansdowne Ave, Merrick
(516) 992-0004 – sportsmanli.com
Time to stock up on sporting goods! If you’re specifically in need of ammo or other hunting equipment, South Shore Sportsman should be the first place you go. Located in Merrick, South Shore Sportsman has built up quite the reputation in the hunting and sporting industries for its vast selection of inventory. Whether you’re a first-time hunter or a seasoned pro, South Shore Sportsman can get you set up with the right equipment, including firearms, ammunition, accessories, and so much more. The store is truly a one-stop shop for hunting enthusiasts from across Long Island. If you’re not sure where to start, the helpful staff at South Shore Sportsman is there to assist you so you can go out there armed with the knowledge to hunt safely!
2021: Long Islanders Voted South Shore Sportsman Best Sporting Goods Store!
South Shore Sportsman
9 Lansdowne Ave, Merrick
(516) 992-0004 – sportsmanli.com
Looking to plan your next hunting adventure in the wilderness? Eager to take the top prize in your next shooting competition? When it comes to shooting and hunting equipment, South Shore Sportsman truly hits the target. Long Island’s top sporting goods store offers the best in firearms, ammunition, optics and hunting accessories at competitive prices. They carry the most reputable brands on the market, including Smith & Wesson, Colt and Remington. South Shore Sportsman fosters a safe and inviting environment where all clients’ questions are answered. Their staff can help recommend the perfect equipment for specific animal seasons and prey. And if you’re a novice at gun sports, they’ll turn you into an expert in no time with instructional lessons. For all your shooting needs, think of South Shore first!
2020: Long Islanders Voted South Shore Sportsman Best Sporting Goods Store!
South Shore Sportsman
9 Lansdowne Ave, Merrick
(516) 992-0004 – sportsmanli.com
Looking to plan your next hunting adventure in the wilderness? Eager to take the top prize in your next shooting competition? When it comes to shooting and hunting equipment, South Shore Sportsman truly hits the target. Long Island’s top sporting goods store offers the best in firearms, ammunition, optics and hunting accessories at competitive prices. They carry the most reputable brands on the market, including Smith & Wesson, Colt and Remington. South Shore Sportsman fosters a safe and inviting environment where all clients’ questions are answered. Their staff can help recommend the perfect equipment for specific animal seasons and prey. And if you’re a novice at gun sports, they’ll turn you into an expert in no time with instructional lessons. For all your shooting needs, think of South Shore first!
Dick’s Sporting Goods (National Winner)
Multiple Locations
(877) 846-9997 – dickssportinggoods.com
Ready to run the bases or head out to the golf course as it gets warm? Perhaps you’re hitting the mountains for a ski-trip or some good old fashioned camping. No matter what your sport is, Dick’s has the gear to get you up and going, from bats and balls to cleats and apparel. The widely known sporting goods store carries the latest products from top brands including Nike, Adidas, Yeti and Under Armour. In addition, they offer a convenient one hour pick-up and free shipping from their online store. Whether you’re in the field, on the ground or in the snow, head to Dick’s to get the gear you need for whatever moves you!
2019: Long Islanders Voted Woodbury Sports Best Sporting Goods Store!
Woodbury Sports
7965 Jericho Tpke., Woodbury
(516) 496-0600 – www.woodburysports.com
From little league glory to a big marathon win, it all starts here at Woodbury Sports. The family-owned and operated shop has all the sporting goods you need in one convenient place. They carry equipment and apparel for all major sports, but specialize in five areas: running, tennis, men’s lifestyle and clothing, and soccer. That means you’ll get expert advice and truly personalized service to help you find exactly what you need. But above all, they are proud of the deep ties they’ve made with local leagues — stop by and get on your way to victory today!
Johnson Fitness & Wellness (National Winner)
203 Mineola Ave., Roslyn Heights
(516) 277-1515 – www.johnsonfitness.com
At Johnson Fitness & Wellness, they believe that change is good, but lasting transformation is great. That’s why they provide the very best guided experience at hundreds of no-pressure retail showrooms staffed by our passionate fitness experts. They’ll personalize your exercise plan, diet and nutrition while providing premium equipment ideal for your uniquely healthy goals. From small changes to complete lifestyle makeovers, they take it one step at a time — together. It takes more than the right equipment to achieve lasting healthy transformations. Certified Fitness Consultants make sure you know how to use the equipment properly and have the right training plan and support in place to be successful. Schedule a complimentary fitness consultation today. As the largest specialty fitness retailer in the U.S., they offer an unmatched selection of award-winning fitness and wellness products from brands like Matrix Fitness, Vision Fitness, Horizon Fitness, Hoist, Octane and more.
2018: Long Islanders Voted South Shore Sportsman Best Sporting Goods Store on Long Island!
South Shore Sportsman
9 Lansdowne Ave
Merrick, NY 11566
(516) 992-0004 – www.sssli.com
Hunting requires expert marksmanship and the right equipment. At South Shore Sportsman you will find a state of the art selection of handguns, rifles, ammunition, and optics is unmatched, as are their prices. The latest gear is always here, with expert sales staff to answer all your questions. If you need cleaning supplies and spare parts, South Shore Sportsman has you covered. They’ll even repair your equipment to have it working like new. Hunters will find a broad selection of decoys, game calls, scent covers, survival supplies, and other essential outdoor gear. Search their broad inventory online and keep up with the latest tech available at South Shore Sportsman.
2017: Long Islanders Voted Camp-Site Sport Shop Best Sporting Goods Store on Long Island!
Camp-Site Sport Shop
1877 New York Ave., Huntington Station. 631-271-4969. campsitesportshop.com
It’s no surprise that Camp-Site Sport Shop is a perennial winner in this category. The uber-popular sporting goods store, which is frequented by outdoorsmen, firearm aficionados, and the parents of Boy Scouts across the Island, has everything anyone would need for a day-hunting, fishing, or long-awaited weekend camping excursion. Not only are its products top-notch, its customer service is praised by its proud and loyal customers, who never skip a chance to stop in at Camp-Site before heading outdoors.
2016: Long Islanders Voted Modell’s Best Sporting Goods Store on Long Island!
Modell’s
Multiple Locations. modells.com
For years Modell’s has been the go-to spot for athletes and fans of professional sports teams to find apparel and gear for high school games. Modell’s is The one-stop shop for all your sporting needs, whether you favor basketball, baseball, football, and hockey, or are just in need of new running sneakers because your previous pair has been ruined by all that jogging. And when our favorite sports team advances to the finals in the respective sports, Modell’s is always ready to open its doors for the onslaught of fanatics teeming with excitement over their team’s historic victory! Go Modell’s!
National Winner: Dick’s Sporting Goods
Multiple Locations. 877-846-9997. dickssportinggoods.com
Whatever the season, whatever the sport, Dick’s Sporting Goods has you covered. The store has become a favorite of parents looking for equipment for their aspiring soccer or softball star in the family. Dick’s has also become a go-to destination for golfers in need of a new five-iron for the upcoming golf season, and sports fanatics dying to get their hands on the jersey of their favorite athlete. You don’t have to be a talented athlete to appreciate all Dick’s has to offer. Anyone in the market for a new bicycle for a leisurely ride around Long Island’s many parks, or running gear, can find exactly what they need at Dick’s.
2015: Long Islanders Voted Camp-Site Sport Shop Best Sporting Goods Store on Long Island!
Camp-Site Sport Shop
1877 New York Ave., Huntington Station. 631-271-4969. campsitesportshop.com
The Camp-Site Sport Shop is getting ready to celebrate its 50th anniversary! Camp-Site carries equipment for hunting, fishing and camping, as well as a great selection of Boy Scouts gear. The shop prides itself on outstanding customer service and high-quality products. If you haven’t been to the shop you have to make it a point make the trip and check it out. Camp-Site’s experienced staff can help customers with any level of experience, and strives to make sure all are satisfied.
2014: Long Islanders Voted Camp-Site Sport Shop in Huntington Station Best Sporting Goods Store on Long Island!
1. Camp-Site Sport Shop
1877 New York Ave., Huntington Station. 631-271-4969. campsitesportshop.com
2. Woodbury Sports
7965 Jericho Tpke., Woodbury. 516-496-0600. woodburysports.com
3. Sports Shack
101 Deer Park Ave., Babylon. 631-669-9836. murphyssportshack.com
NATIONAL
Dick’s Sporting Goods
Multiple Locations. 877-846-9997. dickssportinggoods.com
2013: Long Islanders Voted Campsite Sport Shop in Huntington Station Best Sporting Goods Store on Long Island!
1. Campsite Sport Shop
1877 New York Ave., Huntington Station. 631-271-4969. www.campsitesportshop.com
2. Amity Harbor Sports
149 Merrick Rd., Amityville. 631-691-7505. www.amityharborsports.net
3. Solow Sports
347 W. Main St., Huntington. 631-629-4940. www.solowsports.com
NATIONAL
Dick’s Sporting Goods
Multiple Locations. www.dickssportinggoods.com
2012: Long Islanders Voted South Shore Sportsman in Merrick Best Sporting Goods Store on Long Island!
1. South Shore Sportsman
9 Lansdowne Ave., Merrick. 516-992-0004. www.sportsmanli.com
2. Amity Harbor Sports
149 Merrick Rd., Amityville. 631-691-7505. www.amityharborsports.net
3. Runner’s Edge
242 Main St., Farmingdale. 516-420-7963. www.runnersedgeny.com
NATIONAL
Modell’s
MULTIPLE LOCATIONS. www.modells.com
2011: Long Islanders Voted Lacrosse Unlimited Best Sporting Goods Store on Long Island!
1. Lacrosse Unlimited
Multiple locations. 877-800-5850. www.lacrosseunlimited.com
2. Amity Harbor Sports
149 Merrick Rd., Amityville. 631-691-7505. www.amitysports.net
3. Baseball Plus
400 Duffy Ave., Hicksville. 516-827-5009. www.baseballplusny.com
NATIONAL
Dick’s Sporting Goods
Multiple locations. www.dickssportinggoods.com
2010: Long Islanders Voted Amity Harbor Sports, in Amityville the Best Sporting Goods Store on Long Island!
1. Amity Harbor Sports
149 Merrick Rd., Amityville. 631-691-7505. www.amitysports.net
2. Lacrosse Unlimited
Multiple locations. www.lacrosseunlimited.com
3. Massapequa Soccer & Sport Shop
1004 Park Blvd., Massapequa Park. 516-798-7769. www.massapequasoccer.com