The great thing about sliders is that you can still enjoy a burger, except just in smaller portions. They can also be shared (not that you can’t share a burger, but it’s a lot messier to do that). Long Islanders love their sliders, and restaurant menus all over can attest for that. But like with every other category in this competition, only one could come out on top. Make sure you try the Best Sliders on Long Island.
2024: Long Island Voted Cafe Testarossa Best Sliders!
Cafe Testarossa
499 Jericho Turnpike, Syosset
(516) 364-8877 – cafetestarossa.com
Cafe Testarossa sets the standard for slider perfection on Long Island, boasting a standout dish that leaves taste buds tingling with delight. Their veal meatball sliders, featured on the primi plates menu, are a true culinary masterpiece. Crafted with precision and passion, each bite offers a symphony of flavors that captivates the palate. With tender veal meatballs nestled between soft buns and complemented by savory toppings, these sliders elevate the dining experience to new heights. Whether enjoyed as an appetizer or a main course, Cafe Testarossa’s veal meatball sliders stand as a testament to their commitment to exceptional cuisine and culinary innovation.
2023: Long Islanders Voted Smok-Haus Best Sliders!
Smok-Haus
7 12th St, Garden City
(516) 400-7100 – smokhaus.com
There’s nothing like the bite-sized, tasty goodness of a well-made slider. If you’re looking for flavor-filled sliders on Long Island, visit Smōk-Haus, a Garden City restaurant and bar that specializes in authentic American barbecue. The eatery offers a casual yet comfortable dining experience, and delivery and catering services are also available. From nachos to chili fries to boneless wings and chips, Smōk-Haus has tasty options that will appeal to mostly anyone. Best of all, their prices are reasonable.
2022: Long Islanders Voted One Eye Jacks Best Sliders!
One Eye Jacks
380 N. Wantagh Ave, Bethpage
(516) 342-1732 – oneeyejacksny.com
Who doesn’t love a slider? At One Eye Jacks, the kitchen staff makes the most delicious mini-burgers that you can find on Long Island. Though One Eye Jacks offers plenty of bites to munch on while you enjoy a drink, the meatball sliders are one of its signature items that patrons order time and time again, and when you order it, you’ll see why. The sliders can be topped with a classic marinara sauce or a vodka sauce and topped with parmesan cheese, putting an Italian twist on a favorite bar food. Plus, the bustling atmosphere and expansive alcohol varieties available behind the bar can help you round out the night.
2021: Long Islanders Voted One Eye Jacks Best Sliders!
One Eye Jacks
380 N Wantagh Ave, Bethpage
(516) 342-1732 – facebook.com/oneeyejacksli
Who doesn’t love a slider? At One Eye Jacks, the kitchen staff makes the most delicious mini-burgers that you can find on Long Island. Though One Eye Jacks offers plenty of bites to munch on while you enjoy a drink, the meatball sliders are one of its signature items that patrons order time and time again, and when you order it you’ll see why. The sliders can be topped with a classic marinara sauce or a vodka sauce and topped with parmesan cheese, putting an Italian twist on a favorite bar food. Plus, the bustling atmosphere and expansive alcohol varieties available behind the bar can help you round out the night.
2020: Long Islanders Voted One Eye Jacks Best Sliders!
One Eye Jacks
380 N Wantagh Ave, Bethpage
(516) 342-1732 – facebook.com/oneeyejacksli
It can be tough to find a place that offers solid sliders for a slick meal, but look no further. One Eye Jacks is a “vibing” sports bar that carries the best sliders you’ll find on the island. Run-on over to One Eye Jacks, stay all night if you’d like, and get a solid meal in a buzzing atmosphere. There’s nothing better than savoring your juicy mini-burgers with a drink and great friends, and this bar-restaurant is constantly rolling out new events and parties for its customers to enjoy. Offering a great space to watch the game or celebrate, One Eyes Jacks is a perfect spot to spend a Friday evening or night. With a 4.8 out of 5 recommendation rate on Facebook, it is no wonder why One Eye Jacks is the top spot for sliders that indeed hit the spot!
2019: Long Islanders Voted That Meetball Place Best Sliders!
That Meetball Place
52 W. Main St., Patchogue
(631) 569-5888 – www.thatmeetballplaceli.com
The concept for That Meetball Place began years ago when we realized the simplicity of the meatball, and how it is a comfort food cherished across all age groups and cultures. So many of us grew up with our grandmothers making Sunday dinner where “The Meatball” was the simple and delicious focal point of the entire meal! Their chef has taken his inspiration from those fond memories of food and family and with the freshest ingredients has developed meatballs, salads & sides to satisfy everyone in your family. In creating the first “That Meetball Place” on Main Street in Patchogue in 2014, they were able to provide that great vibe where friends and families gather together to enjoy fresh, simple and delicious food. They are also proud to be a part of the revitalization of Patchogue, a booming Main Street Village.
2018: Long Islanders Voted Slider Joe’s Best Sliders on Long Island
Slider Joe’s
189 N. Long Beach Rd., Rockville Centre. 516-766-2000. sliderjoes.com
Slider Joe’s has earned the top spot in this category, which isn’t an easy task to accomplish! From grilled-cheese beef sliders to cheese sliders sautéed in freshly shaved onions, which are all 100% Angus beef, Slider Joe’s really does live up to its name. Plus, you can add other toppings that you wish, such as tomatoes and lettuce. And the best part: They deliver—not just incredible food, but right to your door!
2017: Long Islanders Voted Slider Joe’s Best Sliders on Long Island
Slider Joe’s
189 N. Long Beach Rd., Rockville Centre. 516-766-2000. sliderjoes.com
Slider Joe’s consistently ranks at the top of this prestigious list, and for great reasons! From grilled-cheese beef sliders to cheese sliders sautéed in freshly shaved onions, which are all 100% Angus beef, Slider Joe’s really does live up to its name. Plus, you can add other toppings that you wish, such as tomatoes and lettuce. And the best part: They deliver—not just incredible food, but right to your door! It’s no wonder why Long Islanders vote Slider Joe’s the absolute Best Sliders on Long Island, year after year!
National Winner: White Castle
Multiple Locations. whitecastle.com
White Castle’s been perfecting their slider since 1921. Since then, their iconic, 2×2-inch beef bombers pressed between a soft, steamed bun and topped with pickle and onions have become synonymous with satisfaction. These lil puppies come in equally iconic sleeves, sacks and cases, because as Long Islanders know all too well: They are addictive!
2016: Long Islanders Voted Slider Joe’s Best Sliders on Long Island
Slider Joe’s
189 N. Long Beach Rd., Rockville Centre. 516-766-2000. sliderjoes.com
Cheese sliders, chicken sliders, 100-percent certified Angus beef sliders, overstuffed pulled pork sliders—Slider Joe’s specializes in all shapes and sizes of these smooth, tasty morsels of joy! Applewood smoked bacon, shaved onions, melted cheddar cheese, BBQ sauce, lettuce and tomato—load up any toppings you wish, Slider Joe’s embodies sheer slider perfection, pressed between soft, steamed buns!
National Winner: White Castle Multiple
Locations. whitecastle.com
White Castle’s been perfecting their slider since 1921. Since then, their iconic, 2×2-inch beef bombers pressed between a soft, steamed bun and topped with pickle and onions have become synonymous with satisfaction. These lil puppies come in equally iconic sleeves, sacks and cases, because as Long Islanders know all too well: They are addictive!
2015: Long Islanders Voted Slider Joe’s Best Sliders on Long Island!
Slider Joe’s 189 N. Long Beach Rd., Rockville Centre. 516-766-2000. sliderjoes.com Ever wish you could get more of those delicious, juicy sliders that came as an appetizer order before your main course? Slider Joe’s enables customers to do just that, and a whole lot more! Made with 100-percent Angus beef and accompanied by various combinations of lettuce, tomato, cheese, sauce, onions and other goodies, stick to your favorites or experiment! Long Islanders say they’re all The Best! National. White Castle Multiple Locations. whitecastle.com These tiny lil fellas go down uber-smooth and come in sacks (10), cases (30) or crates (100). Yes! (Sorry.) They are the original sliders and are simply addictive. Order a sleeve (as many as you can stack together) of double-cheese beef, chicken, or fish sliders, and experience what so many have known for decades: You can toss back way more of these burgers than you ever imagined!
2014: Long Islanders Voted Perabell Food Bar in Patchogue Best Sliders on Long Island!
1. Perabell Food Bar 69 E. Main St., Patchogue. 631-447-7766. perabellfoodbar.com 2. Slider Joe’s 189 N. Long Beach Rd., Rockville Centre. 516-766-2000. sliderjoes.com 3. Johnny Rockets Multiple Locations. johnnyrockets.com NATIONAL White Castle Multiple Locations. whitecastle.com
2013: Long Islanders Voted Churchill’s in Rockville Centre Best Sliders on Long Island!
1. Churchill’s 18 S. Park Ave., Rockville Centre. 516-766-2500. www.churchillsrvc.com 2. Johnny Rockets Multiple Locations. www.johnnyrockets.com 3. Perabell Food Bar 540 Walt Whitman Rd., Patchogue. 631-447-7766 www.perabellfoodbar.com NATIONAL White Castle Multiple Locations. www.whitecastle.com
2012: Long Islanders Voted Rookies Sports Club in Huntington Best Sliders on Long Island!
1. Rookies Sports Club 70 Gerard St., Huntington. 631-923-0424. www.rookiesny.com 2. Johnny Rockets Multiple Locations. www.johnnyrockets.com 3. Teller’s Chophouse 605 Main St., Islip. 631-277-7070. www.tellerschophouse.com NATIONAL White Castle Multiple Locations. www.whitecastle.com
2011: Long Islanders Voted George Martin’s Grillfire Best Sliders on Long Island!
1. George Martin’s Grillfire Multiple Locations. www.georgemartingroup.com 2. The Stone Turtle 4160 Austin Blvd., Island Park. 516-431-6570. www.thestoneturtlerestaurant.com 3. Johnny Rockets Multiple Locations. www.johnnyrockets.com
2010: Long Islanders Voted Johnny Rockets Best Sliders on Long Island!
1. Johnny Rockets Multiple locations. www.johnnyrockets.com 2. John Harvard’s Brew House 2093 Smith Haven Plaza, Lake Grove. 631-979-2739. www.johnharvards.com 3. George Martin’s Grill Fire 13 North Park Ave., Rockville Centre. 516-678-1290. www.georgemartingroup.com NATIONAL Cheesecake Factory Multiple locations. www.cheesecakefactory.com