Jewelry is a gift that carries significant meaning. Whether you’re shopping for a pair of earrings, a necklace, or another fabulous piece, make sure you patronize a trusted source for your jewelry needs. Here are Long Island’s favorites.
2024: Long Island Voted From Italy with Love Best Jewelry Store!
From Italy with Love
473 Old Country Rd, Westbury
(516) 333-3702 – fromitalywithlove.com
Since 1983. From Italy with Love Jewelers has specialized in beautiful, quality jewelry at affordable prices! As a family-owned jewelry store, they serve Long Island with knowledgeable and friendly experts to help customers find jewelry for any occasion from weddings to anniversaries, or just an unforgettable surprise for that special someone. As the jeweler where “quality meets service,” From Italy with Love carries an array of pieces from tennis bracelets and diamond stud earrings to diamond solitaire engagement rings, bridal settings, designer watches, and fashion jewelry of every style for any occasion. Customers rave about the store’s “excellent customer service and beautiful selection.” Visit their store today to see their entire selection of affordable, quality jewelry!
2023: Long Islanders Voted From Italy with Love Best Jewelry Store!
From Italy with Love
473 Old Country Rd., Westbury
(516) 333-3702 – fromitalywithlovejewelers.com
From Italy With Love has been selling beautiful, high-quality fine jewelry to Long Islanders since 1983. The family owned business has stunning jewelry for any occasion, whether you’re about to propose, give a gift to a special someone, or need to buy your own jewelry for an upcoming event. The experts behind the counter have decades of experience to help you choose the right look and fit. And From Italy With Love has it all – from engagement rings and bridal settings to tennis bracelets, diamond stud earrings, and designer watches. The jewelry store is best known for the solid craftsmanship of its pieces. So head on down, and choose from its impressive selection of designs to find an unforgettable gift for someone special or for yourself!
2022: Long Islanders Voted From Italy With Love Best Jewelry Store!
From Italy With Love
473 Old Country Rd. #A, Westbury
(516) 333-3702 – fromitalywithlovejewelers.com
From Italy With Love has been selling beautiful, high-quality fine jewelry to Long Islanders since 1983. The family owned business has stunning jewelry for any occasion, whether you’re about to propose, give a gift to a special someone, or need to buy your own jewelry for an upcoming event. The experts behind the counter have decades of experience to help you choose the right look and fit. And From Italy With Love has it all – from engagement rings and bridal settings to tennis bracelets, diamond stud earrings, and designer watches. The jewelry store is best known for the solid craftsmanship of its pieces. So head on down, and choose from its impressive selection of designs to find an unforgettable gift for someone special or for yourself!
2021: Long Islanders Voted From Italy With Love Best Jewelry Store!
From Italy With Love
473 Old Country Rd, Westbury
(516) 333-3702 – fromitalywithlovejewelers.com
From Italy With Love is a family-owned jewelry store serving Long Island since 1983. Its knowledgeable and friendly experts have almost 30 years of experience, so when you’re ready to pop the question, celebrate an anniversary, or simply surprise a special someone, they’ll be sure to help make the day unforgettable. Whether it’s a tennis bracelet, diamond stud earrings, diamond solitaire engagement ring, bridal setting, designer watch or fashion jewelry of every style for any occasion, From Italy With Love has what you’re looking for. Visit the store today to see their entire selection, or contact them and they’ll be glad to help you find what you’re looking for!
2020: Long Islanders Voted From Italy With Love Best Jewelry Store!
From Italy With Love
473 Old Country Rd, Westbury
(516) 333-3702 – fromitalywithlovejewelers.com
From Italy With Love is a family-owned jewelry store serving Long Island since 1983. Their knowledgeable and friendly experts have almost 30 years of experience, so when you’re ready to pop the question, celebrate an anniversary, or simply surprise a special someone, they’ll be sure to help make the day unforgettable. Whether it’s a tennis bracelet, diamond stud earrings, diamond solitaire engagement ring, bridal setting, designer watch, or fashion jewelry of every style for any occasion, they have what you are looking for. Visit the store today to see their entire selection, or contact them and they’ll be glad to help you find what you’re looking for!
2019: Long Islanders Voted From Italy With Love Best Jewelry Store!
From Italy With Love
473 Old Country Rd. # A, Westbury
(516) 333-3702 – www.fromitalywithlovejewelers.com
From Italy With Love is a family-owned jewelry store serving Long Island since 1983. Their knowledgeable and friendly experts have almost 30 years of experience, so when you’re ready to pop the question, celebrate an anniversary, or simply surprise a special someone, they’ll be sure to help make the day unforgettable. Whether it’s a tennis bracelet, diamond stud earrings, diamond solitaire engagement ring, bridal setting, designer watch, or fashion jewelry of every style for any occasion, they have what you are looking for. Visit the store today to see their entire selection, or contact them and they’ll be glad to help you find what you’re looking for!
2018: Long Islanders Voted From Italy With Love Best Jewelry Store on Long Island!
From Italy with Love
473 Old Country Rod., Westbury. 516-333-3702. fromitalywithlovejewelers.com
This family owned gem of a jewelry store has been serving Long Island for more than three decades and is staffed with a friendly and knowledgeable team of experts who can help customers locate the perfect piece of jewelry, for any occasion. Whether you’re ready to pop the question, celebrate an anniversary, surprise that special someone, or treat yourself to a precious gift, From Italy With Love has it all! With a range of different styles and designs of rings, bracelets, earrings and necklaces, it’s no wonder why voters declare From Italy With Love the Best Jewelry Store on Long Island!
2017: Long Islanders Voted From Italy With Love Best Jewelry Store on Long Island!
From Italy With Love
473 Old Country Rod., Westbury. 516-333-3702. fromitalywithlovejewelers.com
This family owned gem of a jewelry store has been serving Long Island for more than three decades and is staffed with a friendly and knowledgeable team of experts who can help customers locate the perfect piece of jewelry, for any occasion. Whether you’re ready to pop the question, celebrate an anniversary, surprise that special someone, or treat yourself to a precious gift, From Italy With Love has it all! With a range of different styles and designs of rings, bracelets, earrings and necklaces, it’s no wonder why voters declare From Italy With Love the Best Jewelry Store on Long Island!
2016: Long Islanders Voted SVS Fine Jewelry Best Jewelry Store on Long Island!
SVS Fine Jewelry
3323 Long Beach Rd., Oceanside. 516-766-2614. svsfinejewelry.com
Purchasing the perfect piece of jewelry, whether that’s a ring, bracelet, necklace, or set of earrings, is a big deal. The cut, the composition, the stone, the setting, the price—it’s all got to be just right. SVS Fine Jewelry has an amazing inventory, with hundreds of pieces to choose from, and is staffed by a team of expert jewelers who are knowledgeable and friendly. They’ll help you through this process, no matter what you seek, no matter what the occasion, and do their utmost to ensure every patron receives exactly what they’ve been searching for, at exactly the right price. Owner Sami Saatchi is a 10th generation jeweler who can answer any jewelry-related question and create any custom piece, making SVS Fine Jewelry literally one-of-a-kind!
Our staff of highly skilled professionals can accommodate every request whether it is a simple jewelry repair or a custom designed piece made especially for you. Big or small, simple or complex, we provide the same level of care, expertise and courtesy to all. We have a full service repair shop, providing custom designs and will reset your diamonds in front of you. We have a graduate gemologists from GIA (Gemological Institute of America) on staff.
We are the engagement ring specialists at SVS Fine Jewelry. Whether you choose one of our beautiful designer pieces or choose to create a custom ring, SVS Fine Jewelry can make your dreams reality. We use a state of the art custom CAD program to create the perfect piece of jewelry on the computer right in front of you. We can use your stones or supply them to turn your jewelry into a brand new piece. All work is done in-house with you being a part of each step along the way.
SVS Fine Jewelry has been an active member of the Independent Jewelers Organization since 2005.
The Independent Jewelers Organization is a group of over 800 independent retail jewelers nationwide, which offers supreme quality and unmatched service, providing an excellence that customers can count on. As our area’s exclusive Master IJO Jeweler, we maintain a leading role by keeping up with the latest fashions and trends in fine jewelry, educating ourselves about every aspect of our industry, including innovative technologies, and listening carefully to each one of our customers. We are able to offer the finest diamonds in the world at the best value. We practice a strict ethical code of conduct regarding the importance of trust, integrity, expertise, honesty and quality, as it is our promise to deliver the Brilliance You Deserve ®.
2015: Long Islanders Voted Good Old Gold Best Jewelry Store on Long Island!
Good Old Gold
5278 Sunrise Hwy., Massapequa Park. 516-798-5151. goodoldgold.com
When you are in the market for a diamond, do not overlook this “gem” of a jewelry store, where a team of registered gemologists work to bring the most perfect diamonds in the most exciting cuts to Long Island. Rest assured that the experts at Good Old Gold will help you make a smart purchase and achieve the ultimate bang for your buck—a one-of-a-kind selection that will last, well, quite honestly, forever.
My partner and I have just recently bought a diamond from Good Old Gold, and I cannot praise them highly enough! I have never experienced such excellent customer service before…
–Caity Slimming
Staff was incredibly helpful. If you’re looking for a high quality diamond and could use advice and assurances, you will enjoy shopping with GOG…
–Matthew Holt
Good Old Gold has an outstanding reputation for carrying some of the best-cut diamonds available anywhere. The staff is really friendly and helpful…
–Ethan Anderson
Instant Savings: 20% off of all new jewelry items
During checkout, enter coupon code BESTOFLI (case sensitive) to receive your discount. Shop now
2014: Long Islanders Voted Gennaro Jewelers in Bellmore Best Jewelry Store on Long Island!
1. Gennaro Jewelers
410 Bedford Ave., Bellmore. 516-785-0134. gennarojewelers.com
2. Good Old Gold
5278 Sunrise Hwy., Massapequa Park. 516-798-5151. goodoldgold.com
3. SVS Fine Jewelry
3323 Long Beach Rd., Oceanside. 516-766-2614. svsfinejewelry.com
2013: Long Islanders Voted Good Old Gold in Massapequa Park Best Jewelry Store on Long Island!
1. Good Old Gold
5278 Sunrise Hwy., Massapequa Park. 516-798-5151. www.goodoldgold.com
2. Gennaro Jewelers
410 Bedford Avenue North, Bellmore. 516-785-0134. www.gennarojewelers.com
3. The Window Shop Jewelers
104 Main St., Northport. 631-239-5450
2012: Long Islanders Voted The Window Shop Jewelers in Northport Best Jewelry Store on Long Island!
1. The Window Shop Jewelers
104 Main St., Northport. 631-261-0436.
2. Gennaro Jewelers
410 Bedford Ave., Bellmore. 516-785-0134. www.gennarojewelers.com
3. Argyle Jewelers
150 Deer Park Ave., Babylon. 631-321-0800
2011: Long Islanders Voted Great American Jewelry in Massapequa Park Best Jewelry Store On Long Island!
1. Great American Jewelry
5163 Merrick Rd., Massapequa Park. 516-279-6752.
2. Argyle Jewelers
150 Deer Park Ave., Babylon. 631-321-0800.
3. Gennaro Jewelers
410 Bedford Ave., Bellmore. 516-785-0134. www.gennarojewelers.com
2010: Long Islanders Voted Gennaro Jewelers in Bellmore Best Jewelry Store on Long Island!
1. Gennaro Jewelers
410 Bedford Ave., Bellmore. 516-785-0134. www.gennarojewelers.com
2. Mayfair Jewelers
7947 Jericho Tpke., Woodbury. 516-496-8171. 19 Main St., East Hampton. 631-329-8444. www.mayfairrocks.com
3. Good Old Gold
5278 Sunrise Hwy., Massapequa Park. 516-798-5151. www.goodoldgold.com
