The Irish know how to have a good time even when they’re sad, or so the poets say. When you go to an Irish bar on Long Island, you’re guaranteed to enjoy yourself and your friends, complete with the best ales and ska music around, if you’re lucky. The atmosphere is also one that can’t be beat. So if you feel like taking a little trip to the Emerald Isle this year, sans the expensive airfare, then head over to the Best Irish Bar on Long Island.
2024: Long Island Voted Fibber McGee’s Best Irish Bar!
Fibber McGee’s
105 Broadway, Lynbrook
(516) 456-0363 – facebook.com/pages/category/pub/fibbers-mcgees-314386365319339
Fibber McGee’s stands as the epitome of Irish hospitality and charm, solidifying its reputation as the ultimate Irish bar on Long Island. With its cozy atmosphere, lively ambiance, and authentic décor reminiscent of the Emerald Isle, patrons are transported to a spirited world of camaraderie and good craic. From perfectly poured pints of Guinness to hearty Irish fare that warms the soul, every aspect of the Fibber McGee’s experience reflects a dedication to celebrating Irish culture and tradition. Whether enjoying live music, cheering on sporting events, or simply sharing stories with friends old and new, Fibber McGee’s welcomes all with open arms and a warm Irish spirit.
2023: Long Islanders Voted Flanagan’s Best Irish Bar!
Flanagan’s
451 Hawkins Ave, Ronkonkoma
(631) 588-9843 – flanaganspubny.com
There’s nothing like a quintessential Irish bar, and no one does it better than Flanagan’s. They offer the perfect blend of Irish and American cuisine, and their newly redesigned dining room creates the perfect atmosphere for a satisfying meal with friends or family. With a different special for every day of the week and events like bingo, live music, and dance parties, customers keep coming back for more. Flanagan’s also offers catering for any occasion or budget and will work with you to make your event special. The friendly and experienced bar staff have perfected a variety of drinks including seasonal sangrias and cocktails and popular choices like the Blueberry Smash and Limerick Mule. If you’re looking for a pub that makes you feel like one of the family, Flanagan’s is the place to be.
2022: Long Islanders Voted Trinity Restaurant And Bar Best Irish Bar!
Trinity Restaurant And Bar
190 Jericho Tpk, Floral Park
516-358-5584– trinityrestaurant.com
Come for one of the loveliest pours of Guinness you’ll find outside of Ireland, stay for the hospitality. From the second you walk into Trinity Restaurant in Floral Park, you’ll be greeted by the kind staff with a warm smile. The restaurant carries 17 beer selections, including Magners Irish Cider and Smithwick’s Premium Irish Ale, and pub food favorites that include a hearty shepherds pie and buffalo wings that are off-the-bone fantastic and game-day ready. Trinity Restaurant’s warm atmosphere, attentiveness to detail, and friendliness will make you feel like you’re in a quaint, lively pub in Ireland!
2021: Long Islanders Voted Shandon Court Best Irish Bar!
Shandon Court
115 E Main St, East Islip
(631) 581-5678 – shandoncourt.com
At Shandon Court, the sweetest memories are made to last a lifetime. From the moment you step inside the premises, you’re immediately transported to the pubs in Ireland where the bartenders greet you with a wave and smile. Shandon Court serves traditional favorites such as shepard’s pie and corned beef and cabbage along with pub food items. Top off your experience with a pint or two of your favorite Guinness or beer option while listening to live music that’ll have you nodding your head and tapping your fingers to the beat in no time. Whether you’re enjoying a casual dinner or booked a private event, the staff at Shandon Court will help make every moment a happy one!
2020: Long Islanders Voted Trinity Restaurant Best Irish Bar On Long Island!
Trinity Restaurant
190 Jericho Tpke, Floral Park
(516) 358-5584 – trinityrestaurant.com
Come for one of the loveliest pours of Guinness you’ll find outside of Ireland, stay for the hospitality. From the second you walk into Trinity Restaurant in Floral Park, you’ll be greeted by the kind staff with a warm smile. They carry 17 beer selections like Magners Irish Cider and Smithwick’s Premium Irish Ale and pub food favorites that include a hearty Shepherd’s Pie and Buffalo Wings that are-off-the-bone fantastic and game-day ready. Trinity Restaurant’s warm atmosphere, attentiveness to detail and friendliness will make you feel like you’re in a quaint, lively pub in Ireland!
2019: Long Islanders Voted Shandon Court Best Irish Bar On Long Island!
Shandon Court
115 E. Main St., East Islip
(631) 581-5678 – www.shandoncourt.com
Not your typical Irish bar by any means, Shandon Court is like royalty when it comes to serving its customers something that is anything but ordinary. They rise above mediocrity by creating a place where you really want to spend some time with friends you know and friends you haven’t made yet, but you know you will once you toast the good life together. And don’t forget that the kitchen at Shandon Court also knows how to exceed expectations. It doesn’t offer up the same-old pub grub. Every meal is served to perfection in a great setting on the South Shore that pleases the eye as the food satisfies the stomach and restores the soul. Does your spirit need a lift? Then raise a glass at Shandon Court, voted the Best Irish Bar on Long Island!
2018: Long Islanders Voted Shandon Court Best Irish Bar on Long Island
Shandon Court
115 E. Main St., East Islip.
(631) 581-5678. shandoncourt.com
Not your typical Irish bar by any means, Shandon Court is like royalty when it comes to serving its customers something that is anything but ordinary. They rise above mediocrity by creating a place where you really want to spend some time with friends you know and friends you haven’t made yet, but you know you will once you toast the good life together. And don’t forget that the kitchen at Shandon Court also knows how to exceed expectations. It doesn’t offer up the same-old pub grub. Every meal is served to perfection in a great setting on the South Shore that pleases the eye as the food satisfies the stomach and restores the soul. Does your spirit need a lift? Then raise a glass at Shandon Court, voted the Best Irish Bar on Long Island!
2017: Long Islanders Voted Shandon Court Best Irish Bar on Long Island
Shandon Court
115 E. Main St., East Islip. 631-581-5678. shandoncourt.com
Not your typical Irish bar by any means, Shandon Court is like royalty when it comes to serving its customers – something that is anything but ordinary. They rise above mediocrity by creating a place where you really want to spend some time with friends you know and friends you haven’t made yet, but you know you will once you toast the good life together. And don’t forget that the kitchen at Shandon Court also knows how to exceed expectations. It doesn’t offer up the same-old pub grub. Every meal is served to perfection in a great setting on the South Shore that pleases the eye as the food satisfies the stomach and restores the soul. Does your spirit need a lift? Then raise a glass at Shandon Court, voted the Best Irish Bar on Long Island!
2016: Long Islanders Voted The Nutty Irishman Best Irish Bar on Long Island
The Nutty Irishman
Multiple Locations. thenuttyirishman.com
May the road rise to meet you, may the wind be always at your back, may the sun warm your heart and may you have a pint in your hand to slake your thirst! The Irish count their blessings best when happiness comes through the door and the troubles stay far behind. You don’t have to be Irish to be welcomed like one of the Emerald Isle’s far-flung flock at The Nutty Irishman, which has won the great honor of being voted The Best Irish Bar on Long Island. Poetry is in the air! There’s also great live music, the best DJs, and plenty of spirits to go ‘round. Here’s to a cold beer and another one!
2015: Long Islanders Voted Lily Flanagan’s Pub Best Irish Bar on Long Island!
Lily Flanagan’s Pub
345 Deer Park Ave., Babylon. 631-539-0816. lilyflanagans.com
From St. Paddy’s to St. Baldrick’s, the days and nights all go better at Lily Flanagan’s of Babylon, the perfect place for being Irish, thinking Irish and wishing you were Irish. Or, just hanging out with the Irish. Its welcoming staff, tasty food, good cheer and great drinks add up to a wonderful time where the Gaelic vibe feels just right. Erin go bragh!
2014: Long Islanders Voted Lily Flanagan’s – Babylon Best Irish Bar on Long Island!
1. Lily Flanagan’s Pub – Babylon
345 Deer Park Ave., Babylon. 631-539-0816. lilyflanaganspub.com
From St. Paddy’s to St. Baldrick’s, the days and nights all go better at Lily Flanagan’s Pub of Babylon, the perfect place for being Irish, thinking Irish and wishing you were Irish. Or, just hanging out with the Irish. Its welcoming staff, tasty food, good cheer and great drinks add up to a wonderful time where the Gaelic vibe feels just right. Erin go bragh!
2. T.J. Finley’s
42 E. Main St., Bay Shore. 631-647-4856. tjfinleys.com
3. The Nutty Irishman
Multiple Locations. thenuttyirishman.com
2013: Long Islanders Voted TJ Finley’s in Bay Shore Best Irish Bar on Long Island!
1. TJ Finley’s
42 E. Main St., Bay Shore. 631-647-4856. www.tjfinleys.com
2. Finnegan’s
5 Wall St., Huntington. 631-423-9696. www.lessings.com
3. The Nutty Irishman
Multiple Locations. www.thenuttyirishman.com
2012: Long Islanders Voted The Nutty Irishman Best Irish Bar on Long Island!
1. The Nutty Irishman
Multiple Locations. www.thenuttyirishman.com
2. Paddy’s Loft
1286 Hicksville Rd., Massapequa. 516-798-7660. www.paddysloft.com
3. T.J. Finley’s
42 E. Main St., Bay Shore. 631-647-4856. www.tjfinleys.com
2011: Long Islanders Voted Lily Flanagan’s Best Irish Bar on Long Island
1. Lily Flanagan’s
Multiple Locations. www.lilyflanagansbar.com
2. The Nutty Irishman
60 E. Main St., Bay Shore. 631-969-9700; 323 Main St., Farmingdale. 516-293-9700. www.thenuttyirishman.com
3. Finnegan’s Restaurant and Tap Room
5 Wall St., Huntington. 631-423-9696. www.lessings.com
2010: Long Islanders Voted Paddy’s Loft in Massapequa Best Irish Bar on Long Island!
1. Paddy’s Loft
1286 Hicksville Rd., Massapequa. 516-798-7660 www.paddysloft.com
2. The Nutty Irishman
323 Main St. Farmingdale. 516-293-9700. 60 E. Main St., Bay Shore. 631-969-9700. www.thenuttyirishman.com
3. Jackie Reilly’s
3964 Hempstead Tpke. Bethpage. 516-731-7544. www.jackiereillys.com
