Best Greek Restaurant on Long Island

Greek cuisine is so much more than gyros, olives and feta. It incorporates lots of ripe vegetables and fresh fish, as well as yogurt, lamb and pork. From salads and spanakopita to baklava and rizogalo (or rice pudding), these dishes have very Greek names, but their contents have familiar tastes. For the greatest Greek food you’ll ever eat, look no further than the Best Greek Restaurant on Long Island.

2024: Long Island Voted Greek City Grill Best Greek Restaurant!

Greek City Grill
263 Nassau Blvd S., Garden City
(516) 660-6156 – greekcitygrillny.com

Greek City Grille, founded by the ambitious George Charalambous, is a culinary haven nestled in the heart of Garden City. George’s childhood dream of running a business, inspired by his grandfather’s legacy, materialized into this vibrant Greek restaurant. The establishment emanates warmth, resonating with the nostalgia of being the cherished sandwich spot on the boulevard for locals after school. George’s passion for authenticity shines through the menu, featuring mouthwatering Greek delights crafted with pride and joy. With a commitment to spreading happiness through delectable flavors, George aspires to create lasting memories for future generations in Garden City. Greek City Grille stands as a testament to the rich tapestry of Greek culinary traditions, bringing a delightful taste of Greece to the community!

2023: Long Islanders Voted Greek Town – Rockville Centre Best Greek Restaurant (Tie)!

Greek Town – Rockville Centre
90 N. Village Ave., Rockville Centre
(516) 678-4550 – greektownny.com

Greek Town’s philosophy is to make food they’d be proud to serve their own families in Greece. The food is made fresh from scratch using authentic Greek recipes and methods, and it shows in the high quality of every meal. People who get a taste of Greek Town never turn anywhere else, and generations of families keep coming back for more. Every customer has their own favorite order — reviews rave about everything from the warm pita bread to the fresh Greek Goddess salad to the perfectly-made tzatziki sauce. At Greek Town, every bite is a perfect little taste of the Mediterranean!

2023: Long Islanders Voted Pita Bowl Greek Cuisine Best Greek Restaurant (Tie)!

Pita Bowl Greek Cuisine
280A N. Wellwood Ave., Lindenhurst
(631) 226-7482 – eatatpitabowl.com

Don’t sacrifice flavor for convenience: Pita Bowl Greek Cuisine is the best place for a quick, delicious bite! With deep family roots in Greece, every option on the Pita bowl menu is packed with flavor and authenticity. There are vegetarian and gluten-free options, making their food accessible to everyone. A fan-favorite, the Build-Your-Own bowl, lets you customize a bowl full of all your favorite Mediterranean flavors. Pita Bowl’s quick service and generous portions make it one of the most popular community staples around, and the fresh ingredients and eco-friendly bowls make it a great choice for the environmentally conscious diner. Whether you’re a falafel fanatic or crazy for kourambiedes, Pita Bowl Greek Cuisine is the place to go!

2022: Long Islanders Voted Athenian Greek Taverna Best Greek Restaurant!

Athenian Greek Taverna
2188 Jericho Tpke, Commack
(631) 499-7660 – atheniangreektaverna.com

If you’re looking for a Greek meal cooked “Yiayia’s way” (grandma’s way), look no further than Athenian Greek Taverna. As one of Commack’s premier restaurants, Athenian is the place to find the most delectable traditional Greek fare, whether it’s for lunch, dinner, or catering. Since Athenian’s opening, Greek-American brothers John and Chef Alex Homenides have offered guests a chance to taste time-tested family recipes, using fresh and authentic ingredients delivered daily. Their menu has a variety of options for you to pick and choose from, including sandwiches and gyros, a kebab corner for flame roasted and skewered meats, a fillet bar stacked with fish options, and much more. They also have Yiayia’s classics, of course, with options like fresh eggplant dish and spanakopita (traditional Greek spinach pie). When you go Greek, go here!

2021: Long Islanders Voted Athenian Greek Taverna Best Greek Restaurant!

Athenian Greek Taverna
2188 Jericho Tpke, Commack
(631) 499-7660 – atheniangreektaverna.com

If you’re looking for a Greek meal cooked “Yiayia’s way,” (grandma’s way) — look no further than Athenian Greek Taverna. As one of Commack’s premier restaurants, Athenian is the place to find the most delectable traditional Greek fare, whether it’s for lunch, dinner or catering. Since Athenian’s opening, Greek-American brothers John and Chef Alex Homenides have offered guests a chance to taste time-tested family recipes, using fresh and authentic ingredients delivered daily. Their menu has a variety of options for you to pick and choose from, including sandwiches and gyros, a kebab corner for flame roasted and skewered meats, a fillet bar stacked with fish options, and much more. They also have Yiayia’s classics, of course, with options like fresh eggplant dish and spanakopita (traditional Greek spinach pie). When you go Greek, go here!

2020: Long Islanders Voted Akropolis Best Greek Restaurant!

Akropolis Restaurant
127-16 Smithtown Blvd, Nesconset
(631) 979-0924 – akropolisrestaurant.com

Getting a taste of Greece is more accessible than you think. At Akropolis Restaurant, they take pride in providing their customers a truly authentic Greek dining experience with their expansive menu selection. From gyros to souvlaki dinners to Greek salads, each dish is prepared using the freshest, high-quality ingredients. While you wait for your food to be ready, enjoy a complimentary side of pita bread with chickpeas. Whether you’re dining in or ordering take-out, the staff Akropolis Restaurant will ensure that your meal is as delicious and flavorful so you’ll come back for more.

2019: Long Islanders Voted Neraki Greek Mediterranean Best Greek Restaurant!

Neraki Greek Mediterranean
273 Main St., Huntington
(631) 385-3474 – www.neraki.com

When the mood for Mediterranean cuisine strikes, there is no better place to satisfy that urge than Neraki Greek Mediterranean Grill in Huntington. They take special care to present the delicacies that call your name, like a feta-filled Greek salad with chunks of white meat chicken grilled to perfection, to lamb, eggplant and falafel specialties. Be sure to try the stuffed grape leaves. And don’t you dare leave without sampling some grilled octopus! Trust Long Island voters, this place is that fantastic!

2018: Long Islanders Voted Neraki Greek Mediterranean Best Greek Restaurant on Long Island

Neraki Greek Mediterranean
273 Main St., Huntington. 631-385-3474. Neraki.com
When the mood for Mediterranean cuisine strikes, there is no better place to satisfy that urge than Neraki Greek Mediterranean Grill in the Village of Huntington. They take special care to present the delicacies that call your name, like feta filled Greek salad with chicken, homemade Pastichio and Mousaka. Be sure to try one of the many whole fish they offer because they are grilled perfection. And don’t you dare leave without sampling some grilled octopus. Trust Long Island voters, this place is fantastic!!

2017: Long Islanders Voted Neraki Greek Mediterranean Best Greek Restaurant on Long Island

Neraki Greek Mediterranean
273 Main St., Huntington. 631-385-3474. Neraki.com
When the mood for Mediterranean cuisine strikes, there is no better place to satisfy that urge than Neraki Greek Mediterranean Grill in Huntington. They take special care to present the delicacies that call your name, like a feta-filled Greek salad with chunks of white meat chicken grilled to perfection, to lamb, eggplant and falafel specialties. Be sure to try the stuffed grape leaves. And don’t you dare leave without sampling some grilled octopus! Trust Long Island voters, this place is that fantastic!

2016: Long Islanders Voted Ayhan’s Shish Kebab Best Greek Restaurant on Long Island

Ayhan’s Shish Kebab
Multiple Locations. ayhansrestaurants.com
Ayhan’s Shish-Kebab Mediterranean Restaurants got voted the best Greek restaurant on Long Island because customers love how well they prepare this delicious cuisine. Whether it’s hummus, Greek salad, spinach pie or Avgolemeno lemon soup, to name a few delicious offerings, they’re always a sure bet. Ayhan started this journey on Long Island more than 35 years ago with his original venue in Port Washington. Then he went further, expanding his presence on the Island and broadening his presentation on the menu with great Greek seafood along with authentic dishes and beverages from the eastern Mediterranean region. Their gyros are one of a kind—nobody can match their amazing taste. It’s a gift!

2015: Long Islanders Voted Neraki Greek Mediterranean Grill Best Greek Restaurant on Long Island!

Neraki Greek Mediterranean Grill
273 Main St., Huntington. 631-385-3474. neraki.com

When the mood for Mediterranean cuisine strikes, there is no better place to satisfy that urge than Neraki Greek Mediterranean Grill in Huntington. They take special care to present the delicacies that call your name, like a feta filled Greek salad with chunks of white meat chicken grilled to perfection, to lamb, eggplant, and falafel specialties. Try the stuffed grape leaves—and don’t you dare leave without sampling some grilled octopus! Trust Long Island voters, this place is that fantastic!

2014: Long Islanders voted Neraki in Huntington Best Greek Restaurant on Long Island!

1. Neraki
273 Main St., Huntington. 631-385-3474. neraki.com

2. Greek Town
90 N. Village Ave., Rockville Centre. 516-678-4550.

3. Ayhan’s Shish Kebab
Multiple Locations. ayhansrestaurants.com

2013: Long Islanders Voted Ayhan’s Shish Kebab Best Greek Restaurant on Long Island!

1. Ayhan’s Shish Kebab
Multiple Locations. www.ayhansrestaurants.com

2. Santorini Greek Restaurant
133 Merrick Ave., Merrick. 516-867-5175

3. Limani
1043 Northern Blvd., Roslyn. 516-869-8989. www.limaniny.com

2012: Long Islanders Voted Santorini Greek Restaurant in Merrick Best Greek Restaurant on Long Island!

1. Santorini Greek Restaurant
133 Merrick Ave., Merrick. 516-867-5175.

2. Ayhan’s Shish Kebab
Multiple Locations. www.ayhansrestaurants.com

3. Opa Grill
505 Stewart Ave., Bethpage. 516-933-1062. www.theopagrille.com

2011: Long Islanders Voted Aegean Cafe Best Greek Restaurant on Long Island

1. Aegean Café
35 Main St., Sayville. 631-589-5529. www.sayvilleaegeancafe.com