Frozen yogurt was all the rage over the last year, and it thankfully still is one of the most popular summer treats. So many shops have opened up on Long Island that there’s bound to be one within a five-mile radius of anyone’s house (and that’s never a bad thing). So whether you prefer vanilla over chocolate or raspberry over strawberry, you’ll have to at least try the Best Frozen Yogurt on Long Island.
2024: Long Island Voted Port Jefferson Ice Cream Café Best Frozen Yogurt!
Port Jefferson Ice Cream Café
30 Chandler Square, Pt Jefferson
(631) 384-2282 – facebook.com/pjicecreamcafe
Indulge in a delectable frozen yogurt experience at Port Jefferson Ice Cream Café, showcasing the most scrumptious treats across Long Island. Boasting over 20 rotating flavors, there’s a delightful option to satisfy every palate. This café has consistently delivered innovative and mouthwatering frozen yogurt and ice cream creations, setting itself apart on Long Island. Say goodbye to mundane chain stores and immerse yourself in the imaginative offerings of Port Jefferson Ice Cream Café for an unparalleled sweet escape. Not only does it promise the finest frozen yogurt on Long Island, but it also provides an authentic and irresistible ice cream adventure that entices patrons to return time and time again. Revel in flavors as enchanting as the charm of downtown Port Jeff!
2023: Long Islanders Voted Moolala Best Frozen Yogurt!
Moolala
1664 Merrick Rd, Merrick
(516) 442-3577 – facebook.com/moolalafrozenyogurt
Moolala has an atmosphere that is inviting, family friendly, and fun! The staff prides themselves on making delicious, non-fat, kosher certified, gluten-free, authentic yogurt. Best of all, Moolala flavors and toppings change all time, so each visit brings a new experience! The Moolala Rewards mobile app delivers special offers and loyalty information to on-the-go customers, providing quick access to exclusive deals, enrollment options, loyalty point balance and rewards lookup, loyalty program information, and more. Moolala Frozen Yogurt offers rewards enrollment with password protection, rewards access, business information, and awards that make their tasty treats even more affordable.
2022: Long Islanders Voted Port Jefferson Ice Cream Café Best Frozen Yogurt!
Port Jefferson Ice Cream Café
30 Chandler Sq, Port Jefferson
631-384-2282 – facebook.com/pjIceCreamCafe
Port Jefferson Ice Cream Café offers the most delicious frozen yogurt found anywhere on all of Long Island. With more than 20 rotating flavors, you’ll find something delicious to meet your tastes. It has been serving some of the most innovative flavors of delicious frozen yogurt and ice cream treats on Long Island. Next time you’re craving a sweet treat, skip the boring chain store and head straight to the creative Port Jefferson Ice Cream Café instead. Not only will you get the best frozen yogurt on Long Island, but you’ll also get an authentic ice cream experience that keeps customers coming back again and again! It tastes as beautiful as downtown Port Jeff looks!
2021: Long Islanders Voted 16 Handles Best Frozen Yogurt!
16 Handles
40 Middle Neck Rd, Great Neck
(516) 858-0405 – 16handles.com
Even in the winter, there’s nothing quite like a frozen yogurt treat — and there’s nothing quite that treat from 16 Handles. This fan favorite shop is known for helping you celebrate your individuality (or unleash your inner “Fro-Yo chef”) by offering a wide variety of frozen yogurt flavors and all the toppings you could think of, so you can create your perfect fro-yo. 16 Handles has locations in New York City and Long Island, including its popular location in Great Neck at 40 Middle Neck Road that’s conveniently located near the Great Neck Train Station. All of its 16+ frozen yogurts flavors, such as fan favorites rich dark roast coffee and birthday cake, are gluten free. Not in the mood for a frozen yogurt? Easy, make it a smoothie. It’s always a good time to treat yo’self!
2020: Long Islanders Voted Fusion Yogurt and Bowls (Formerly Swirls and Twirls of West Islip) Best Frozen Yogurt!
Fusion Yogurt and Bowls (Formerly Swirls and Twirls of West Islip)
494 Union Blvd, West Islip
(631) 661-0010 – swirlsandtwirlsusa.com
Whip up your frozen concoction at Fusion Yogurt and Bowls, the best place to go for fro-yo on Long Island. Fusion Yogurt and Bowls is no “vanilla” frozen yogurt shop; they carry exciting flavors that include everything from birthday cake batter and cinnamon roll and cotton candy and gingerbread cookie. All options are low fat, fat free or gluten free, so you can indulge while being kind to your waistline. Don’t forget to load up your creation with sweet toppings like gummy words, berries or chocolate. With more than 24 premium flavors on tap and more than 50 toppings to choose from, you’ll never have a lack of choice. Grab a cup and get swirling!
2019: Long Islanders Voted Swirls & Twirls of West Islip Best Frozen Yogurt!
Swirls & Twirls of West Islip
494 Union Blvd., West Islip
(631) 661-0010 – www.swirlsandtwirlsusa.com
At Swirls and Twirls, they are all about promoting creative expression – in all forms. Creativity is the process of bringing something new into being. It’s about being original, curious, adventurous and open minded. It’s about asking questions, coming up with new answers and most importantly, it’s about self expression. Swirls and Twirls is the ultimate healthy indulgence. Self- serve frozen yogurt that is delicious, nutritious and loads of fun to make. They have designed their store to put you in control. They’ll give you a cup and a spoon, 24 premium flavors on tap and more than 50+ toppings to choose from. The rest is up to you!
Red Mango (National Winner)
Multiple Locations
www.redmangousa.com
Order up one of these stomach-pleasing yogurt sundaes, “Fro-Yo Mashups,” parfaits, “Skinny Sorbettos” and smoothies and watch as the friendly staff happily plop handfuls of fresh fruit into those blenders, swirling and churning those beautiful messes around into a colorful, healthy elixir that will help you along your way and make you feel fantastic! Order up the banana-strawberry heal-all and discover for yourself why so many Long Islanders rank these must-stop shops The Best!
2018: Long Islanders Voted Treasure Island Desserts Best Frozen Yogurt on Long Island
Treasure Island Desserts
2575 Hempstead Tpke., East Meadow. 516-261-9900. treasureislanddesserts.com
Strawberry shortcake and cookies n’ cream and fun fudge brownie, oh my! And those are just a few of the flavors offered at Treasure Island Desserts. Founded by a determined Hofstra University graduate, Treasure Island Desserts is truly a gem hidden right in East Meadow, just waiting for more Long Islanders to discover it. And it doesn’t just stop at frozen yogurt—this shop also offers various gelato and ice cream flavors, along with a bunch of tasty toppings, such as butterfingers, caramel, and raspberries, to enjoy with your snacks!
2017: Long Islanders Voted Treasure Island Desserts Best Frozen Yogurt on Long Island
Treasure Island Desserts 2575 Hempstead Tpke., East Meadow. 516-261-9900. treasureislanddessert.com Strawberry shortcake and cookies n’ cream and fun fudge brownie, oh my! And those are just a few of the flavors offered at Treasure Island Desserts. Founded by a determined Hofstra University graduate, Treasure Island Desserts is truly a gem hidden right in East Meadow, just waiting for more Long Islanders to discover it. And it doesn’t just stop at frozen yogurt—this shop also offers various gelato and ice cream flavors, along with a bunch of tasty toppings, such as butterfingers, caramel, and raspberries, to enjoy with your snacks!
2016: Long Islanders Voted Berry Good Frozen Yogurt Cafe Best Frozen Yogurt on Long Island
Berry Good Frozen Yogurt Cafe 14 E. Main St., Patchogue. 631-289-1700. berrygoodfrozenyogurtcafe.com Offering 21 flavors of creamy, delicious self-serve frozen yogurt and nearly 70 toppings to choose from, Long Islanders know that Berry Good Yogurt Cafe is the spot for that healthy, digestion-friendly treat. The largest frozen yogurt cafe around, Berry Good features a rotating array of flavors and is devoted to quality, assuring each generous helping is replete with live, active yogurt cultures to soothe your mind, body and spirit!
2015: Long Islanders Voted Moolala Frozen Yogurt Best Frozen Yogurt on Long Island!
Moolala Frozen Yogurt Multiple Locations. moolalayogurt.com Serving delicious, healthy yogurt teeming with those uber-gut-friendly live and active cultures and probiotics, Moolala does the body good! With a dozen flavors and countless topping combinations to choose from, this local yogurt spot will have your belly shouting “Moolala! Moolala! Moolala!” after just one lip-smacking cup! National. Red Mango Multiple Locations. redmangousa.com Order one of their yogurt sundaes, “Fro-Yo Mashups,” parfaits, “Skinny Sorbettos” and smoothies and watch as the friendly staff happily plops handfuls of fresh fruit into blenders, swirling and churning the fruit into a colorful, healthy elixir that will make you feel fantastic! Discover why so many Long Islanders rank these must-stop shops The Best!
2014: Long Islanders Voted Swirls & Twirls Best Frozen Yogurt on Long Island!
1. Swirls & Twirls Multiple Locations. swirlsandtwirlsusa.com 2. Moo La La 1664 Merrick Rd., Merrick. 516-442-3577. 3. 16 Handles Multiple Locations. 16handles.com NATIONAL Red Mango Multiple Locations. redmangousa.com
2013: Long Islanders Voted Moo La La in Merrick Best Frozen Yogurt on Long Island!
1. Moo La La 1664 Merrick Rd., Merrick. 516-442-3577. www.moolalayogurt.com 2. Swirls & Twirls Multiple Locations. www.swirlsandtwirlsusa.com 3. Yogurt Crazy Multiple Locations. www.yogurtcrazyonline.com NATIONAL Red Mango Multiple Locations. www.redmangousa.com
2012: Long Islanders Voted Moolala in Merrick Best Frozen Yogurt on Long Island!
1. Moolala 1664 Merrick Rd., Merrick. 516-442-3577. www.moolalayogurt.com 2. Tutti Frutti 28 W. Park Ave., Long Beach. 516-442-7222. www.tfyogurt.com 3. Serve Your Self 141 Central Park Rd., Plainview. 516-342-6190. www.serveyourselfli.com NATIONAL Red Mango Multiple Locations. www.redmangousa.com