Being that Long Island is surrounded by water, the fish are certainly plenty…not to mention delicious. The island has many different great fish markets thanks to its waterfront cities and hamlets, selling everything from salmon and halibut to trout and tilapia. For only the best in seafood this year, look no further than the Best Fish Market on Long Island. There’s surely nothing fishy about it.
2024: Long Island Voted The Fish Store – Bayport Best Fish Market!
The Fish Store – Bayport
836 Montauk Hwy, Bayport
(631) 472-3018 – thefishstoreonline.com
It’s time to delve into the secrets anyone filled with desire for our island’s seaside bounty already knows. Customers say go check out The Fish Store. The Bayport fish market is where you will pick up fresh fish, of course, live lobsters, and prepped yummy dinners to take home and enjoy or treat your guests. There’s catering too. Among cooked entrees, you’ll want to try Chilean sea bass, salmon, calamari, baked clams, oysters Rockefeller, and there’s much more. A sushi chef is an artist here taking pride in the fresh sashimi you might try both counties-wide. Give Sashimi Deluxe a whirl and find out the unique varieties of fish generously portioned and cut meticulously. Counter service is impeccably attended by The Fish Store staff.
2023: Long Islanders Voted The Fish Store – Bayport Best Fish Market!
The Fish Store – Bayport
836 Montauk Hwy, Bayport
(631) 472-3018 – thefishstoreonline.com
The Fish Store is a family-run fish specialty shop in Bayport that serves fresh caught fish and shellfish in a cozy and casual eatery with an attached market. Through their commitment, experience, and expertise, The Fish Store has established a business relationship with their customers that will last a lifetime. All year long, The Fish Store provides top-notch fresh fish, live lobsters, dinners to go, catering services, and much more, along with great customer service – a combination that cannot be beat! Considering the many health benefits of seafood and/or shellfish, The Fish Store is certainly worth a visit if you’re attempting to plan a particularly healthy meal.
2022: Long Islanders Voted The Fish Store Best Fish Market!
The Fish Store
836 Montauk Hwy., Bayport
(631) 472-3018 – thefishstoreonline.com
Founded in 1978, The Fish Store provides top-notch fresh fish, live lobsters, dinners to go, catering, and more. Combine all the shop’s great food options with excellent customer service and this combination motivates customers to consistently come back for more. Through their commitment to excellence, the team at The Fish Store has established a relationship with customers that will last a lifetime. Joining them in their beautiful restaurant is a treat, where you can enjoy fresh cut fish prepared daily, clams and oysters on the half shell, lobster dinners, and much more. They also serve wine and local beer on tap, including Blue Point Brewery’s seasonal beers. The Fish Store regularly holds tours of the facility, featuring everything from demonstrations of fish cutting to viewing local fresh products.
2021: Long Islanders Voted The Fish Store Best Fish Market!
The Fish Store
836 Montauk Hwy, Bayport
(631) 472-3018 – thefishstoreonline.com
Founded in 1978, The Fish Store provides top-notch fresh fish, live lobsters, dinners To go, catering and more, along with great customer service – a combination that can’t be beat! Through its commitment, experience and expertise, The Fish Store has established a relationship with customers that will last a lifetime. Join them in their beautiful restaurant, where you can enjoy fresh cut fish cooked to order for you daily, lobster dinners, clams on the half shell, oysters on the half shell, and much much more. They also serve wine and local beer on tap including Blue Point Brewery Seasonal beers. The Fish Store regularly holds field trips of their facility and features everything from demonstrations of fish cutting to viewing local fresh products.
2020: Long Islanders Voted The Fish Store Best Fish Market!
The Fish Store
836 Montauk Hwy, Bayport
(631) 472-3018 – thefishstoreonline.com
Founded in 1978, The Fish Store provides top-notch fresh fish, live lobsters, dinners to go, catering and more, along with great customer service – a combination that can’t be beaten! Through their commitment, experience, and expertise The Fish Store has established a business relationship with customers that will last a lifetime! Join them in their beautiful restaurant. You can enjoy fresh cut fish cooked to order for you daily, lobster dinners, clams on the half shell, oysters on the half shell, and much much more. They also serve wine and local beer on tap including Blue Point Brewery Seasonal beers. They regularly hold field trips of their facility and feature everything from demonstrations of fish cutting to viewing local fresh products.
2019: Long Islanders Voted The Fish Store Best Fish Market!
The Fish Store
836 Montauk Hwy., Bayport
(631) 472-3018 – www.thefishstoreonline.com
Founded in 1978, The Fish Store provides top-notch fresh fish, live lobsters, dinners to go, catering and more, along with great customer service – a combination that can’t be beaten! Through their commitment, experience, and expertise The Fish Store has established a business relationship with customers that will last a lifetime! Join them in their beautiful restaurant. You can enjoy fresh cut fish cooked to order for you daily, lobster dinners, clams on the half shell, oysters on the half shell, and much much more. They also serve wine and local beer on tap including Blue Point Brewery Seasonal beers. They regularly hold field trips of their facility and feature everything from demonstrations of fish cutting to viewing local fresh products.
2018: Long Islanders Voted The Fish Store Best Fish Market on Long Island
The Fish Store
836 Montauk Hwy., Bayport. 631-472-3018. thefishstoreonline.com
Once again, the Fish Store has been named the Best Fish Market on Long Island! Having opened in 1978, this family-owned business goes above and beyond to ensure that their customers are provided with the freshest fish, whether caught locally or from other parts of the world. This includes shrimp, wild salmon, cod, mussels, squid, oysters, lobster tails—the list goes on and on! Their flounder is even cut right on the premises. Plus, now you can stay a while, as The Fish Store has also opened a restaurant, allowing customers to enjoy both great seafood and great company!
2017: Long Islanders Voted The Fish Store Best Fish Market on Long Island
The Fish Store 836 Montauk Hwy., Bayport. 631-472-3018. thefishstoreonline.com For the fourth year in a row, The Fish Store has been named the Best Fish Market on Long Island! Having opened in 1978, this family owned business goes above and beyond to ensure that their customers are provided with the freshest fish, whether caught locally or from other parts of the world. This includes shrimp, wild salmon, cod, mussels, squid, oysters, lobster tails—the list goes on and on! Their flounder is even cut right on the premises. Plus, now you can stay a while, as The Fish Store has also opened a restaurant, allowing customers to enjoy both great seafood and great company!
2016: Long Islanders Voted The Fish Store Best Fish Market on Long Island
The Fish Store 836 Montauk Hwy., Bayport. 631-472-3018. thefishstoreonline.com To be crowned The Best fish market on Long Island, a few things are guaranteed: Its inventory must be fresh, and varied. Its staff must be knowledgeable. It must offer exceptional customer service, to the point where customers become like family. The Fish Store meets all this criteria, in spades, and much more. Family owned and operated, this special shop has been providing Long Islanders with the freshest fish and most insightful fish-related tips since its founding in 1978. High-quality fresh fish, live lobsters, catering, dinners to go, and so much more, The Fish Store maintains a tradition of excellence that resonates with voters, loud and clear! Ahoy!
2015: Long Islanders Voted The Fish Store Best Fish Market on Long Island!
The Fish Store 836 Montauk Hwy., Bayport. 631-472-3018. thefishstoreonline.com Established in 1978, this family-run business specializes in the freshest local fish. Boasting everything from live lobsters to hand-cut flounder on-premises, The Fish Store goes the extra Nautical Mile to ensure the freshest quality seafood. Its newest addition, an absolutely beautiful restaurant, gives loyal customers another option to enjoy their fish. Buy it fresh, order one of their to freshly-prepared Meals To Go or stay and enjoy a sit down dinner. Come on down and say hello to Seth and his family team of specialists while they help you select the Best fish! Remember: “Eat Healthy, Eat Fish!”
2014: Long Islanders Voted The Fish Store in Bayport Best Fish Market on Long Island!
1. The Fish Store 836 Montauk Hwy., Bayport. 631-472-3018. thefishstoreonline.com 2. Jordan’s Lobster Farm 1 Pettit Pl., Island Park. 516-889-3314. jordanlobsterfarms.com 3. Two Cousins Fish Market 255 Woodcleft Ave., Freeport. 516-379-0793. twocousinsfishmarket.com
2013: Long Islanders Voted Jordan Lobster Farms in Island Park Best Fish Market on Long Island!
1. Jordan Lobster Farms 1 Pettit Place, Island Park. 516-889-3314. www.jordanlobsterfarms.com 2. Two Cousins Fish Market 225 Woodcleft Ave., Freeport. 516-379-0793 3. Uncle Giuseppe’s Multiple Locations. www.uncleg.com