Want pancakes at midnight, but your friend wants a burger? And how about that other friend who wants a gyro? Don’t fret—a diner is exactly the place for you all to go. And luckily for you all, there’s practically a diner on every corner on Long Island. There’s nothing you can’t get at these classic American restaurants, and that’s precisely why we love them so much. So for a cheap, delicious meal picked from a menu with a wide variety of choices, look no further than the Best Diner on Long Island.
2024: Long Island Voted Lindenhurst Diner Best Diner!
Lindenhurst Diner
195 E Montauk Highway, Lindenhurst
(631) 991-8600 – lindenhurstdiner.com
The Lindenhurst Diner is a beloved business, serving up delicious comfort food and friendly service since its inception. Nestled in the heart of Lindenhurst, this family-owned diner offers a welcoming atmosphere where patrons can enjoy a diverse menu of classic American fare, from hearty breakfasts to savory sandwiches, burgers, salads, and more! Known for its generous portions and affordable prices, the Lindenhurst Diner caters to diners of all ages and tastes, making it a go-to spot for families, friends, and solo diners alike. With its cozy booths, retro decor, and attentive staff, the Lindenhurst Diner provides a nostalgic dining experience that keeps customers coming back for more, time and time again!
2023: Long Islanders Voted Lindenhurst Diner Best Diner!
Lindenhurst Diner
195 E Montauk Hwy., Lindenhurst
(631) 991-8600 – lindenhurstdiner.com
When you walk into The Lindenhurst Diner, you’re immediately greeted by the friendly staff who make you feel like family at this family business. With their expansive menu full of diner classics with a modern twist and a full vegan menu, it’s no wonder they’ve been voted best diner by their customers for the fourth time! A team of chefs led by executive chef Nicholas Hannides make everything from scratch everyday, including their soups, sauces, dressings, and so much more. Owner Peter Glykos orders only the highest quality of food to come together perfectly in each made-to-order dish. All of their breads are delivered fresh daily and their burgers are a special blend made only for The Lindenhurst Diner. Hungry for more? Their delectable desserts are made fresh by a local bakery and their over-the-top milkshakes are what dreams are made of!
2022: Long Islanders Voted Lindenhurst Diner Best Diner!
Lindenhurst Diner
195 E Montauk Hwy., Lindenhurst
(631) 991-8600 – lindenhurstdiner.com
There aren’t many things Long Islanders love more than a good diner. And there aren’t many diners they love more than Lindenhurst. Fans rave about their scrumptious full vegan menu that knocks the socks off the local competition with cheesy apps and entrees. Classic diner fare such as pancakes and omelets also get christened with delicious twists and toppings. Perfectly fried starters, specialty burgers, and frothy shakes served in mason jars all have regulars coming back with friends. The Lindenhurst diner currently offers dine-in, curbside pickup, delivery, and takeout.
2021: Long Islanders Voted Lindenhurst Diner Best Diner!
Lindenhurst Diner
195 E Montauk Hwy, Lindenhurst
(631) 991-8600 – lindenhurstdiner.com
There aren’t many things Long Islanders love more than a good diner. And there aren’t many diners they love more than Lindenhurst. Fans rave about their scrumptious full vegan menu that knocks the socks off the local competition with cheesy apps and entrees. Classic diner fare such as pancakes and omelets also get christened with delicious twists and toppings. Perfectly fried starters, specialty burgers, and frothy shakes served in mason jars all have regulars coming back with friends. The Lindenhurst diner currently offers curbside, delivery, takeout, and car hop service. Those looking for a sit-down meal, however, will find properly distanced tables, shields, and hand sanitizer in sweet containers at every table. Outdoor seating is also available for diners who want to bask in the sun or avoid the indoors altogether.
2020: Long Islanders Voted CJ’s Coffee Shop Best Diner!
CJ’s Coffee Shop
225 N Long Beach Rd, Rockville Centre
(516) 766-9107 – cjscoffeeshop.com
CJ’s Coffee Shop has amassed an impressive number of accolades over the years, and being selected as the best diner in Long Island for the third time in four years is another one to add to the list. The family-owned restaurant has been operating in Rockville Centre since 1979 and serves up an impressive breakfast and lunch menu not limited to pancakes, sandwiches and burgers with a side of coffee and traditional chocolate and vanilla milkshakes. At CJ’s, their mission is to provide home-cooked food without the stresses that come with cleaning up afterwards in an environment that evokes the nostalgia of a 1950s diner and leave you with a smile!
2019: Long Islanders Voted Lindenhurst Diner Best Diner!
Lindenhurst Diner
195 E. Montauk Hwy., Lindenhurst
(631) 991-8600 – www.lindenhurstdiner.com
At Lindenhurst Diner, they like to say they offer restaurant quality at diner prices with chef-crafted meals, with so many huge highlights on the menu. They also deliver. You can even get something nice after dark, with half-price beers and appetizers after 9 p.m. They know that, especially in the New York area and in a place like Long Island, there’s nothing quite like having your own friendly neighborhood diner to visit every now and then. Lindenhurst Diner understands that it is their job to serve the community with delicious food no matter what time of day. They serve breakfast, lunch and dinner every day at reasonable prices. Every day, people come in to Lindenhurst Diner and get the same quality food at a price affordable for everyday folks across Long Island.
2018: Long Islanders Voted CJ’s Coffee Shop Best Diner on Long Island
CJ’s Coffee Shop
225 N. Long Beach Rd., Rockville Centre. 516-766-9107. cjscoffeeshop.com
An old-fashioned vibe, family-friendly service and maybe the best coffee for miles around combine to make CJ’s Coffee Shop a real winner in this coveted category. For breakfast, its pancakes and bacon have legions of fans, and its daily homemade lunch specials will please the wallet as much as the belly. A recent sampling included a “Blue Plate Special” quiche with a salad along with a beverage and a cup of homemade soup and a grilled chicken-avocado-melted mozzarella “Panini of the Day” spritzed with balsamic dressing and served with mac salad. These platters won’t bust your budget—they’ll blow your mind. And make sure you leave room for dessert. You’ll be glad you did!
2017: Long Islanders Voted CJ’s Coffee Shop Best Diner on Long Island
CJ’s Coffee Shop
225 N. Long Beach Rd., Rockville Centre. 516-766-9107. cjscoffeeshop.com
An old-fashioned vibe, family-friendly service and maybe the best coffee for miles around combine to make CJ’s Coffee Shop a real winner in this coveted category. For breakfast, its pancakes and bacon have legions of fans, and its daily homemade lunch specials will please the wallet as much as the belly. A recent sampling included a “Blue Plate Special” quiche with a salad along with a beverage and a cup of homemade soup and a grilled chicken-avocado-melted mozzarella “Panini of the Day” spritzed with balsamic dressing and served with mac salad. These platters won’t bust your budget—they’ll blow your mind. And make sure you leave room for dessert. You’ll be glad you did!
2016: Long Islanders Voted Thomas’ Ham and Eggery Best Diner on Long Island!
Thomas’s Ham & Eggery Diner
325 Old Country Rd., Carle Place. 516-333-3060.
Nothing says Long Island like a great diner, but with so many venues competing for this coveted title, it’s really saying something that Thomas’ Ham and Eggery has earned the nod as The Best diner on Long Island, year after year. It’s the service, the offerings, and the experience that make it so special. You can order your eggs delivered to your table in a sizzling frying pan, or savor a hot stack of fluffy pancakes dripping with maple syrup. But maybe you’re not in the mood for breakfast, and you want lunch or dinner. Don’t worry about it! They’ve got sandwiches by the score, and so much more you may never want to leave until you’ve tried every item on the menu!
2015: Long Islanders Voted Thomas’ Ham & Eggery Best Diner on Long Island!
Thomas’ Ham & Eggery
325 Old Country Rd., Carle Place. 516-333-3060
With so many diners across the Island, the winner of this category has really just got to be something mind-blowingly special. Long Islanders in the know realize that the dishes served at Thomas’ Ham and Eggery are not only delicious, but iconic. Order your eggs delivered in a frying pan brought to your table. Sample the fluffiest pancakes, drizzled in warm syrup. Or try one of their oversized sandwiches for a diner experience you’ll never forget. Trust us, this place is paradise!
2014 Long Islanders Voted Thomas’ Hamd and Eggery in Carle Place Best Diner on Long Island!
1. Thomas’ Ham & Eggery
325 Old Country Rd., Carle Place. 516-333-3060.
2. Empress Diner
2490 Hempstead Tpke., East Meadow. 516-796-0858.
3. Landmark Diner
1027 Northern Blvd., Roslyn. 516-627-4830. landmarkdineronline.com
2013: Long Islanders Voted Landmark Diner in Roslyn Best Diner on Long Island!
1. Landmark Diner
1027 Northern Blvd., Roslyn. 516-627-4830. www.landmarkdineronline.com
2. O-co-nee East Diner
749 Main St., Islip. 631-581-2663
3. Thomas’ Ham & Eggery
325 Old Country Rd., Carle Place. 516-333-3060
2012: Long Islanders Voted Landmark Diner in Roslyn Best Diner on Long Island!
1. Landmark Diner
1027 Northern Blvd., Roslyn. 516-627-4830. www.landmarkdineronline.com
2. Empress Diner
2490 Hempstead Tpke., East Meadow. 516-796-0858.
3. Peter Pan Diner
989 Bay Shore Rd., Bay Shore. 631-665-1788. www.peterpandiner.com
2011: Long Islanders Voted Landmark Diner in Roslyn Best Diner on Long Island!
1. Landmark Diner
1027 Northern Blvd., Roslyn. 516-627-4830. www.theoriginallandmarkdiner.com
2. Empress Diner
2490 Hempstead Tpke., East Meadow. 516-796-0858.
3. Oconee East Diner
749 Main St., Islip. 631-581-2663.
2010: Long Islanders Voted the Massapequa Diner in Massapequa Best Diner on Long Island!
1. Massapequa Diner
4420 Sunrise Hwy., Massapequa. 516-799-5234.
2. Empress Diner
2490 Hempstead Tpke., East Meadow. 516-796-0858.
3. Peter Pan Diner
854 Sunrise Hwy., Bay Shore. 631-665-1788. www.peterpandiner.org
