Delis are probably the best places to stop for a quick, freshly made sandwich during your lunch break at work. There are tons of different cold cuts and cheeses to choose from, not to mention condiments and sides to go with it. Long Islanders love their delicatessens because they offer so much more than the average grocery store deli, and that’s why it was probably incredibly hard for them to choose which one would come out on top in this competition. This year, make sure to stop at the Best Delicatessen on Long Island for a meaty and delicious sandwich, and don’t forget the chips!
2024: Long Island Voted Teresa’s Lunch Box Deli Best Delicatessen!
Teresa’s Lunch Box Deli
758 Park Avenue, Huntington
(631) 351-8721 – teresaslunchboxdeli.com
Teresa’s Lunch Box Deli offers a wide assortment of breakfast and lunch specialties. Whether a classic egg sandwich or coffee to specialty heroes, a fresh chopped salad bar or daily homemade hot entrees, this not your typical deli! Operating for almost 25 years in NYC, this is Teresa’s first location on Long Island. Teresa herself, has been dedicated to providing a great menu, using top quality ingredients, along with a Mediterranean flare rooted in her Greek and Italian heritage. Whether it be the authentic Greek extra virgin olive oil, her infamous Teresa’s Tuscan Spice or the wide variety of Fresh baked breads and bagels delivered from Brooklyn daily, flavor and freshness is always a top priority. Teresa’s Lunch Box prides itself in offering friendly, quick, customer service and maintains a very serious commitment to cleanliness, so you can be sure to have a great experience every time!
2023: Long Islanders Voted Greenway Deli Best Delicatessen!
Greenway Deli
110 Broadway, Greenlawn
(631) 754-9574 – greenwaydeli.com
What makes Greenway Deli the best delicatessen on Long Island? For starters, the freshness of its ingredients cannot be beat. When you grab an egg sandwich or a lunch special from Greenway Deli, you know that the bread is freshly homemade to perfection and that the best cold cuts are being used. Greenway Deli also makes its soups and salads in house for a completely fresh meal any day of the week. Locals love grabbing breakfast and some groceries there or ordering from the extensive catering menu when they have company over. Greenway also offers pickup and delivery. So stop on by and see why Greenway Deli is loved by so many on the Island.
2022: Long Islanders Voted Greenway Deli Best Delicatessen!
Greenway Deli
110 Broadway, Greenlawn
631-754-9574 – greenwaydeli.com
What makes Greenway Deli the best delicatessen on Long Island? For starters, the freshness of its ingredients cannot be beat. When you grab an egg sandwich or a lunch special from Greenway Deli, you know that bread is freshly homemade to perfection and that the best cold cuts are being used. Greenway Deli also makes its soups and salads in house for a completely fresh meal any day of the week. Locals love grabbing breakfast and some groceries there or ordering from the extensive catering menu when they have company over. Greenway also offers pickup and delivery. So stop on by and see why Greenway Deli is loved by so many on the island.
2021: Long Islanders Voted Tamburino’s Deli Best Delicatessen!
Tamburino’s Deli
672 Central Ave, Cedarhurst
(516) 295-2769 – facebook.com/Tamburinos-Italian-American-Deli-Inc
Operating a successful deli on Long Island is no easy feat. In order to rise above the competition, delis need to be more than a place that prioritizes convenience. It needs to serve the highest quality of food at the most accessible of prices. And Tamburino’s Deli in Cedarhurst does this like no other delicatessen around. Conveniently located in the Five Towns, it serves a wide variety of sandwiches, soups, salads and macaroni that’ll have you plan your next visit to the area. Whether you’re looking for a quick lunch option, or need catering for a work event, let Tamburino’s Deli take care of the rest!
2020: Long Islanders Voted A & S Pork Store and Deli Best Delicatessen!
A & S Pork Store and Deli
929 N Broadway, Massapequa
(516) 799-4332– asporkstoreexpress.com
You don’t want to get your deli meats from just anywhere. A & S Pork Store and Deli in Massapequa has been serving up prime Italian meats since 1967 and has become a household name over the years. In addition to offering classic Italian meats and cheeses, A & S Pork Store and Deli serves up specialty sandwiches, homemade sauces and real Italian bread. The food is unmatched and the staff is friendly and knowledgeable about their meat, so you can rest easy knowing that you are going home with the best cut of meat.
2019: Long Islanders Voted Ben’s Kosher Delicatessen & Caterers Best Delicatessen!
Ben’s Kosher Delicatessen & Caterers
140 Wheatley Plaza, Greenvale
(516) 621-3340 – www.bensdeli.net
Ben’s Kosher Delicatessen’s fresh deli offerings attract lunchtime visitors looking for a simple sandwich or salad. Ben’s Kosher Delicatessen is a local eatery that serves up both gluten-free and low-fat dishes. Whether it’s just you and a date or you’re bringing the whole gang, it’s best to call ahead and make a reservation. Casual dining at its best, Ben’s Kosher Delicatessen customers are free to enjoy themselves in jeans and a T-shirt. This restaurant accommodates your schedule. Pick it up yourself or have it delivered to your door. Throwing a big party? Count on Ben’s Kosher Delicatessen to provide top-notch catering with the same great dishes you love. Ben’s Kosher Delicatessens mid-range cuisine will please your pockets as well as your palate. Isn’t it time you visited Ben’s Kosher Delicatessen for a deli that ensures its products are always high quality?
2018: Long Islanders Voted Seaqua Delicatessen & Caterers Best Delicatessen on Long Island
Seaqua Delicatessen & Caterers 4250 Jerusalem Ave., Massapequa 516-799-5600 seaquadeli.com
Bagels, salads, sandwiches, wraps, paninis, hot plates—whatever you crave, Seaqua has got. This gem of a deli has been serving the very finest breakfast, lunch, dinner and snack options since 1983, when father-son team Bob and Pat Spates decided to open shop. Seaqua’s breakfast sandwiches are legendary, as evident from the hordes of hungry Long Islanders who visit every single weekend. With so many options and such fantastic service, not to mention a sister location in St. James, it’s no wonder why so many crown Seaqua The Best, year after year!
2017: Long Islanders Voted Tamburino’s Italian American Deli, Inc. Best Delicatessen on Long Island
Tamburino’s Italian American Deli, Inc.
672 Central Ave., Cedarhurst. 516-295-2769. facebook.com/Tamburinos-Italian-American-Deli-Inc-336387369786974/
Every neighborhood needs a deli that people can rely on for the best sandwiches, seafood platters, and pasta dishes. Lucky for Cedarhurst residents, their deli is the best on Long Island! Tamburino’s Italian American Deli offers a number of breakfast, lunch and dinner options that will make every customer want to come back for more. Craving a hardy hero loaded with lettuce, tomatoes, and chicken? No problem. Want a dynamite shrimp parmigiana? Check. Whatever it is you’re looking for, Tamburino’s has it!
2016: Long Islanders Voted Seaqua Delicatessen & Caterers Best Delicatessen on Long Island
Seaqua Delicatessen & Caterers
4250 Jerusalem Ave., Massapequa. 516-799-5600. seaquadeli.com
Bagels, salads, sandwiches, wraps, paninis, hot plates—whatever you crave, Seaqua has got. This gem of a deli has been serving the very finest breakfast, lunch, dinner and snack options since 1983, when father-son team Bob and Pat Spates decided to open shop. Seaqua’s breakfast sandwiches are legendary, as evident from the hordes of hungry Long Islanders who visit every single weekend. With so many options and such fantastic service, not to mention a sister location in St. James, it’s no wonder why so many crown Seaqua The Best, year after year!
2015: Long Islanders Voted Seaqua Delicatessen & Caterers Best Delicatessen on Long Island!
Seaqua Delicatessen & Caterers
4250 Jerusalem Ave., Massapequa. 516-799-5600. seaquadeli.com
Just visit this amazing deli on any given Sunday morning and you’ll understand why they’re at the top of this list: exceptional service, outstanding variety and sandwiches that are simply to die for, from towering dagwoods to breakfast and egg heroes that are overstuffed with everything from melted cheese, home fries, sausage and bacon (not to mention the eggs) you’ll think you’re living on a farm and get all the fresh goodies the second they hit the table! Sooo good!
2014: Long Islanders Voted Iavarone Bros. Best Delicatessen on Long Island!
1. Iavarone Bros.
Mulitple Locations. 877-IBFOODS. ibfoods.com
2. Seaqua Deli
4250 Jerusalem Ave., Massapequa. 516-799-5600. seaquadeli.com
3. Ben’s Kosher Delicatessan
Multiple Locations. bensdeli.net
2013: Long Islanders Voted Ben’s Kosher Delicatessen Best Delicatessen on Long Island!
1. Ben’s Kosher Delicatessen
Multiple Locations. www.bensdeli.net
2. Iavarone Bros.
Multiple Locations. www.ibfoods.com
3. Jeco’s Deli & Catering
217 Smithtown Blvd., Nesconset. 631-361-7101
2012: Long Islanders Voted Iavarone Bros Best Delicatessen on Long Island!
1. Iavarone Bros.
Multiple Locations. www.ibfoods.com
2. Joe’s Meat & Gourmet Deli
783 Hillside Ave., New Hyde Park. 516-326-7616. www.joesgourmetdeli.com
3. Ben’s Kosher Delicatessen
Multiple Locations. www.bensdeli.net
2011: Long Islanders Voted Ben’s Kosher Delicatessen Best Delicatessen on Long Island!
1. Ben’s Kosher Delicatessen
Multiple locations. www.bensdeli.net
2. Iavarone Bros.
Multiple Locations. 877-IBFOODS. www.ibfoods.com
3. Seaqua Delicatessen
4250 Jerusalem Ave., Massapequa. 516-799-5600. www.seaquadeli.com
2010: Long Islanders Voted Iavarone Bros. The Best Delicatessen On Long Island!
1. Iavarone Bros.
Multiple locations. www.iavaronebros.com
2. Gemelli Fine Foods
115 E. Main St., Babylon. 631-321-4515. www.gemellis.com
3. Seaqua Deli
4250 Jerusalem Ave., Massapequa. 516-799-5600. www.seaquadeli.com