When it comes to buying or selling a home, working with a boutique real estate agency offers a personalized, high-quality experience. With a team of under 50 brokers, these agencies provide hands-on service, local expertise, and a tailored approach to every transaction. Whether you’re searching for your dream home or looking to make the most of your property sale, the best boutique agencies combine market knowledge with a client-first mindset. If you’re looking for top-tier real estate professionals with a personal touch, see which firm our readers have voted as the Best Real Estate Boutique Agency (Under 50 Brokers) on Long Island.
2025: Long Island Voted Blue Island Homes Best Real Estate Boutique Agency (Under 50 Brokers)!
Blue Island Homes
2878 Merrick Road, Bellmore
(516) 613-3600 – blueislandhomesny.com
Blue Island Homes, recently awarded Best Boutique Real Estate Agency on Long Island by Long Island Press, is redefining real estate with expertise, integrity, and unmatched client service. As a premier, full-service brokerage, we specialize in residential sales, new developments, and probate transactions across Long Island. Our team of dedicated professionals, backed by industry-leading experience, delivers personalized strategies to homeowners, buyers, and investors alike. Whether selling, buying, or developing, Blue Island Homes is committed to excellence—because your home is more than just a place; it’s a legacy. Discover the Blue Island difference.
2024: Long Island Voted Northshore Properties Realty Best Real Estate Boutique Agency (Under 50 Brokers) (Tie)!
Northshore Properties Realty
175 Main St, Suite 1g, Setauket
(631) 625-4500 – northshorepropertiesrealty.com
Northshore Properties Realty stands out as a stellar boutique-style real estate agency in Setauket-East Setauket, Long Island. Boasting a team led by the experienced Gina Lollo, this agency, with under 50 brokers, excels in providing a personalized touch to the emotional process of buying or selling a home. Recognizing the profound connection between trust and solid relationships, Northshore prioritizes establishing and maintaining this rapport with clients. From the initial consultation to the final transaction, clients can trust that they are in capable hands. Specializing in downsizing, the agency extends its expertise to cater to diverse needs. For those seeking a seamless and trustworthy real estate experience, Northshore Properties Realty is the go-to boutique agency on Long Island!
2024: Long Island Voted Goldilocks Real Estate Best Real Estate Boutique Agency (Under 50 Brokers) (Tie)!
Goldilocks Real Estate
22 Jericho Turnpike, Mineola
(516) 874-3033 – goldilocksrealestate.com
Much like the fairytale, Goldilocks Real Estate puts its emphasis on “just right,” whether you’re buying, selling or renting a house, condo or co-op. As a boutique agency serving all of Long Island and Queens, Goldilocks Real Estate specializes in “Just right” solutions and believes that no sale is too small or too big to handle. Clients receive the same quality service and expertise whether they’re renting a one-bedroom apartment, purchasing a co-op, a condo, a parcel of land, a single-family home, a multi-family home, a commercial property or a very large estate. Goldilocks Real Estate isn’t too big or small, they’re “Just Right” for you! Call one of their experienced agents today to schedule a consultation. Let Goldilocks Real Estate find your “Just Right” solution!
2023: Long Islanders Voted Northshore Properties Realty Best Real Estate Boutique Agency (Under 50 Brokers)!
Northshore Properties Realty
175 Main St, Suite 1g, Setauket
(631) 625-4500 – northshorepropertiesrealty.com
Buying or selling a house can be stressful at times. Northshore Properties Realty is here to help. The team of highly skilled brokers at Northshore Properties Realty know the ins and outs of the real estate market and will help you get the best possible deal on your future home. From the beginning of the home buying or selling journey to the end, your Northshore Properties Realty broker will be with you every step of the way and will help you understand every part of the process so you can alleviate your stress. Be sure to give the agency a call when it comes time to take the next step to find your perfect home.
2022: Long Islanders Voted Goldilocks Real Estate Best Real Estate Boutique Agency (Under 50 Brokers)!
Goldilocks Real Estate
22 Jericho Tpke, Mineola
(516) 874-3033 – goldilocksrealty.com
Goldilocks Real Estate is esteemed for a long list of reasons. Agents are extremely professional and always go the extra mile for their clients. They address your concerns, and every piece of information they offer is highly relevant. In a nerve-racking time when properties need to be bought or sold, a calming resource is available at your convenience. Finding your way to one of Long Island’s highly trained and experienced real estate pros at Goldilocks allows you to be able to step forward and receive the highest level of attentiveness. It’s their approach that makes it a no-brainer to likely recommend these pros to anyone you know already stressing about trying to sell or buy a home!
2021: Long Islanders Voted Northshore Properties Realty Best Real Estate Boutique Agency (Under 50 Brokers)!
Northshore Properties Realty
175 Main St #1G, Setauket
(631) 625-4500 – northshorepropertiesrealty.com
Buying or selling a house can be stressful at times. Northshore Properties Realty is here to help. The team of highly skilled brokers at Northshore Properties Realty know the ins and outs of the real estate market and will help you get the best possible deal on your future home. From the beginning of the home buying or selling journey to the end, your Northshore Properties Realty broker will be with you every step of the way and will help you understand every part of the process so you can alleviate your stress. Be sure to give the agency a call when it comes time to take the next step to find your perfect home.
2020: Long Islanders Voted Northshore Properties Realty Best Boutique Realty (Under 50 Brokers)!
Northshore Properties Realty
175 Main St #1G, Setauket
(631) 625-4500 – northshorepropertiesrealty.com
Northshore Properties Realty offers many ways to find your dream home. Whether you are looking for a bachelor pad, minimal apartment, penthouse or some quiet land in the countryside, Northshore’s general and advanced searches can help you find the perfect place to settle down. You can choose your minimum and maximum amount of bedrooms and bathrooms as well as define your specific price range and area you are looking for; these filters bring down the stress of trying to find your ideal place. Trust Northshore to help you find the property you are looking for.