Long Island is a boater’s paradise. From the waters of the Great South Bay to the roar of the Atlantic Ocean, our proximity to water makes boaters very, very happy. And boats need supplies: from safety equipment to ornamental details to personalize your boat, Long Island has plenty of stores to take care of all of your boating needs. Here are the best!
2024: Long Island Voted Long Island Boat Rentals Best Boat Store!
Long Island Boat Rentals
403 Main St, Suite 5, Port Washington
(516) 761-0840 – liboatrentals.com
Long Island Boat Rentals provides an unparalleled opportunity to explore the picturesque waters surrounding Long Island! This premier boat rental service offers a fleet of well-maintained vessels, perfect for a day of adventure on the water. Whether it’s cruising along the coastline, fishing in the bays, or enjoying water sports with friends and family, Long Island Boat Rentals caters to all preferences and occasions. With options ranging from pontoon boats to fishing boats and luxury yachts, there’s something for everyone to enjoy. The knowledgeable staff at Long Island Boat Rentals ensures a seamless rental experience, providing safety instructions and insider tips for navigating the local waterways. For an unforgettable aquatic adventure, Long Island Boat Rentals is the ultimate choice!
2023: Long Islanders Voted Long Island Boat Rentals Best Boat Store!
Long Island Boat Rentals
403 Main St., Suite 5, Port Washington
(516) 761-0840 – liboatrentals.com
If you’re looking for someplace to rent a boat, Long Island Boat Rentals is the Island’s premier boating service. Located on Manhasset Bay in Port Washington, they offer bareboat rentals of 21’-27’ bowriders for experienced boaters (8-10 passengers max) plus captained rentals and yacht charters (6 passengers max) so you can enjoy boating the Gold Coast style. Host parties or entertain business guests with gatherings on the water via “Elixir,” Long Island Boat Rentals’ new custom-designed party yacht! It fits 24 guests for an unmatched private luxury yachting experience. Plus, you can receive boat training with semi-private classes, get qualified to rent, and then enjoy 15% off five rentals in the same season. You can also join the Carefree Boat Club for unlimited boating with over 80 locations in the U.S.!
2022: Long Islanders Voted Long Island Boat Rentals Best Boat Store!
Long Island Boat Rentals
403 Main St, Port Washington
(516) 761-0840 – LIBoatRentals.com
Long Island Boat Rentals is the Island’s premier boating service. Located on Manhasset Bay in Port Washington, it offers bareboat rentals of 13’-27’ bowriders for experienced boaters plus captained rentals and yacht charters so you can enjoy boating in Gold Coast style. Long Island Boat Rentals’ floating dock party “Flarty” accommodates 24 guests, also available for rent to private boat owners. Get boat training with semi-private classes or join the Carefree Boat Club for unlimited boating. Long Island Sound offers some of the best boating in the world and Long Island Boat Rentals loves sharing the experience with its clients!
2021: Long Islanders Voted Long Island Boat Rentals Best Boat Store!
Long Island Boat Rentals
403 Main St, Port Washington
(516) 761-0840 – liboatrentals.com
Long Island Boat Rentals is the Island’s premier boating service. Located on Manhasset Bay in Port Washington, it offers bareboat rentals of 13’-27’ bowriders for experienced boaters plus captained rentals and yacht charters so you can enjoy boating in Gold Coast style. Host your parties or entertain business guests with gatherings on the water. “ Elixir ” is its new custom-designed party yacht for 24 guests, an unmatched private luxury yachting experience, launching Spring 2021. Long Island Boat Rentals’ floating dock party “Flarty” accommodates 24 guests, also available for rent to private boat owners. Get boat training with semi-private classes or join the Carefree Boat Club for unlimited boating. Long Island Sound offers some of the best boating in the world and Long Island Boat Rentals loves sharing the experience with its clients.
2020: Long Islanders Voted Coneys Marine Best Boat Store!
Coneys Marine
32 New York Ave, Huntington
(631) 421-3366 – coneys.com
Whether you’re a captain in the making or an experienced explorer of the high seas, your vessel awaits you at Coneys Marine. The full-service marina specializes in the sale of new yachts and the brokerage of new sailboats. Coneys carry a wide selection of family friendly Catalina Yachts, known for their durability, beautiful design and spaciousness. They also provide a wide range of services ranging from mast stepping and bottom painting to engine maintenance and repair. Coneys is happy to house your boat during both the summer and winter seasons, and operates a mooring service within Huntington Harbor. Visit them in their showroom, shop or yard and set sail today!
2019: Long Islanders Voted Star Island Yacht Club & Marina Best Boat Store!
Star Island Yacht Club & Marina
59 Star Island Rd., Montauk Point
(631) 668-5052 – www.starislandyc.com
Come to “The End” of Long Island for the beginning of your next fishing or boating trip at Montauk Point. Star Island Yacht Club attracts a wide variety of people year-round with a passion for cruising and fishing. They host many fishing tournaments (including a famous shark tournament held every year), cruising club rendezvous, and catered events, as well as Star Island’s own planned tournaments. The marina offers more facilities and services than any other in the Montauk area, including a large tackle shop, marine equipment and full repair service. Hungry? You can find some great dishes at Star Island Restaurant, naturally featuring locally caught seafood. With all it has to offer, Star Island Yacht Club is an inviting club and marina for everyone!
2018: Long Islanders Voted Star Island Yacht Club & Marina Best Boat Store on Long Island!
Star Island Yacht Club & Marina
59 Star Island Road, Montauk Point
631-668-5052. Starislandyc.com
Come to “The End” of Long Island for the beginning of your next fishing or boating trip at Montauk Point. Star Island Yacht Club attracts a wide variety of people year-round with a passion for cruising and fishing. They host many fishing tournaments (including a famous shark tournament held every year), cruising club rendezvous, and catered events, as well as Star Island’s own planned tournaments. The marina offers more facilities and services than any other in the Montauk area, including a large tackle shop, marine equipment and full repair service. Hungry? You can find some great dishes at Star Island Restaurant, naturally featuring locally caught seafood. With all it has to offer, Star Island Yacht Club is an inviting club and marina for everyone.
2017: Long Islanders Voted Star Island Yacht Club & Marina Best Boat Store on Long Island!
Star Island Yacht Club & Marina
59 Star Island Rd., Montauk Point. 631-668-5052. starislandyc.com
What can you say? Star Island Yacht Club & Marina is a perennial winner in the Best of Long Island program—and just as it has the two previous years, Star Island notched another win in the “Best Boat Store” category. Why? That’s easy. The yacht club’s shop carries all the essential boating supplies a professional sea-navigator would need: from various types of bait and marine supplies to equipment and outerwear. What’s more, you can stop over at the Star Island Grill for a bite after docking your boat and perusing the famously supply stocked shop. If that’s not enough, this go-to boat store is open year-round, so even when the magical summers on Long Island fade away, Star Island will still be open to meet all your boating needs.
2016: Long Islanders Voted Star Island Yacht Club & Marina Best Boat Store on Long Island!
Star Island Yacht Club & Marina
59 Star Island Rd., Montauk Point. 631-668-5052. starislandyc.com
Star Island Yacht Club & Marina is where boaters go to escape when they want to enjoy time on their boat, outfit it with the latest technologies, or grab a bite at Star Deck Restaurant. The shop, which carries all the essential boating supplies and is staffed by experts oozing with passion, is a one-stop spot for anyone’s boating needs. It boasts everything, from various types of bait, marine supplies and equipment, and top-notch cleaning material. Moreover, the shop is open year-round, giving customers the opportunity to peruse the store even when the weather is not ideal for boating. It’s no surprise that Long Islanders voted Star Island Yacht Club & Marina The Best for a second consecutive year!
2015: Long Islanders Voted Star Island Yacht Club & Marina Best Boat Store on Long Island!
Star Island Yacht Club & Marina
59 Star Island Rd., Montauk Point. 631-668-5052. starislandyc.com
Boaters across the region consider Star Island Yacht Club & Marina the go-to spot for electrical supplies and fishing products. The shop offers a vast assortment of boating supplies and also boasts a full repair service! Its expert staff and the fully stocked shop have everything you’d need, whether you’re a professional boater or someone who enjoys a few hours out at sea. Don’t forget to pick up a bite at Star Deck Restaurant while you’re there!
2014: Long Islanders Voted Amity Harbor Marine in Amityville Best Boat Store on Long Island!
1. Amity Harbor Marine
30 Merrick Rd., Amityville. 631-842-1280. amityharbormarine.com
2. Star Island Yacht Club & Marina
59 Star Island Rd., Montauk Point. 631-668-5052. starislandyc.com
3. White Water Marine
5500 Sunrise Hwy., Sayville. 631-567-4040. whitewaterboats.com
2013: Long Islanders Voted Star Island Yacht Club & Marina in Montauk Point Best Boat Store on Long Island!
1. Star Island Yacht Club & Marina
59 Star Island Rd., Montauk Point. 631-668-5052. www.starislandyc.com
2. Amity Harbor Marine
30 Merrick Rd., Amityville. 631-842-1280. www.amityharbormarine.com
3. Coneys Marine
32 New York Ave., Huntington. 631-421-3366. www.coneys.com
2012: Long Islanders voted Bridge Marine in Bayville Best Boat Store on Long Island!
1. Bridge Marine
19 Ludlam Ave., Bayville. 516-628-8686. www.bridgemarinesales.com
2. Fred Chall Marine Supply
5 Atlantic Ave., Freeport. 516-868-0177. www.fcmsupply.com
3. Surfside 3
Multiple Locations. www.surfside3east.com
2011: Long Islanders Voted Amity Harbor Marine in Amityville Best Boat Store on Long Island!
1. Amity Harbor Marine
30 Merrick Rd., Amityville. 631-842-1280. www.amityharbormarine.com
2. Surfside 3
Multiple locations. www.marinemax.com
3. Fred Chall Marine
124 Woodcleft Ave., Freeport. 631-761-6193. www.fredchallmarine.com
2010: Long Islanders Voted Fred Chall Marine the Best Boat Store on Long Island!
1. Fred Chall Marine
124 Woodcleft Ave., Freeport. 516-546-8960. www.fredchallmarine.com
2. Surfside 3
846 S. Wellwood Ave., Lindenhurst. 631-957-5900. www.marinemax.com
3. The Boat Place
3 Beach St., Port Jefferson. 631-473-0612. www.theboatplaceinc.com