Crispy bacon, fresh lettuce, and juicy tomato layered between toasted bread—there’s a reason the BLT is a timeless favorite. Simple yet satisfying, a well-made BLT is all about using the freshest ingredients and just the right balance of flavors. Long Island is home to countless delis and diners putting their own twist on this classic sandwich. If you’re craving the perfect BLT, see which spot our readers have voted as the Best BLT on Long Island.
2025: Long Islanders Voted Smok-Haus Best BLT!
Smok-Haus
7 12th St, Garden City
(516) 400-7100 – smok-haus.com
At Smok-Haus, their twist on the classic BLT elevates the traditional sandwich to a whole new level. The Smok-Haus PBLT is made with smoked pork belly, adding a rich, savory depth to the dish. Fresh lettuce, ripe tomatoes, and the signature Alabama white BBQ sauce are layered on a soft, toasted potato roll, delivering a perfect balance of textures and flavors. For those looking to make it a complete meal, the PBLT can be paired with a small side, such as crispy fries or a refreshing coleslaw. This unique variation on a simple favorite has quickly become a customer favorite, offering a fresh take on an American classic. The Smok-Haus PBLT is a dish that will satisfy those seeking both quality ingredients and bold flavors.
2024: Long Island Voted Lindenhurst Diner Best BLT!
Lindenhurst Diner
195 E Montauk Highway, Lindenhurst
(631) 991-8600 – lindenhurstdiner.com
Lindenhurst Diner is a staple in the community and well-known for its delicious diner favorites, including the iconic BLT sandwich. This beloved diner’s BLT features crispy bacon, fresh lettuce, and ripe tomatoes nestled between slices of homestyle toast and served with house-made coleslaw and a delectable pickle. Each bite is a symphony of textures and tastes, making the BLT a standout favorite among patrons. With its commitment to quality ingredients and impeccable preparation, Lindenhurst Diner continues to captivate diners with its delicious and comforting fare, making it a cherished destination for locals and visitors alike.
2023: Long Islanders Voted Lindenhurst Diner Best BLT!
Lindenhurst Diner
195 E. Montauk Hwy, Lindenhurst
(631) 991-8600 – lindenhurstdiner.com
An ultimate classic, a perfect union, and a match like no other: The Lindenhurst Diner’s BLT. Made with generous portions of applewood smoked top quality bacon, fresh lettuce, and juicy tomatoes on crunchy, homestyle toast. Ideal for breakfast, lunch, and even dinner, you’ll find no greater BLT on the Island. To complete this tasteful adventure, each BLT is served with The Lindenhurst Diner’s house-made coleslaw and a delectable pickle. Now that’s the kind of BLT you deserve in your life
