What’s old is new to the antique shopper. Treasures wait to be discovered at some of the quaint antique shops that dot our towns along this island. Check out our top picks, then take a drive to browse, peruse, and purchase.
2024: Long Island Voted Remember Yesteryears Best Antique Store!
Remember Yesteryears
901 Montauk Highway, Oakdale
(631) 354-6052 – rememberyesteryears.com
Remember Yesteryears is a captivating emporium offering a nostalgic journey through time. With a curated collection of vintage treasures and unique finds, this antique store beckons collectors and enthusiasts alike! Each item tells a story, from classic furniture pieces to retro decor and rare artifacts. Remember Yesteryears exudes a charming ambiance, inviting patrons to explore the rich tapestry of the past. The knowledgeable and friendly staff adds to the immersive experience, providing insights into the history and provenance of each piece. Whether you’re a seasoned collector or a casual browser, Remember Yesteryears Antique Store is a beacon for those seeking timeless pieces that evoke a sense of history and nostalgia!
2023: Long Islanders Voted Remember Yesteryears Best Antique Store!
Remember Yesteryears
901 Montauk Hwy., Oakdale
(631) 654-3052 – rememberyesteryears.com
Lovers of antiques, collectibles, and all things vintage need to check out Remember Yesteryears! The largest antique center on Long Island, the store is 15,000 square-feet and showcases over 100 dealers. There is nowhere better to hunt for a long sought-after piece, or stumble across an exciting rare find. They’ve got everything — jewelry, clothes, ceramics, paintings, books, furniture, postcards, clocks — the potential is limitless. The endless nooks and crannies are the perfect setting to explore and stumble across a unique piece that would make the perfect addition to your collection, wardrobe, or home. The unbeatable variety of items include both unique handcrafted pieces and vintage name brand finds, making it an ideal location for someone of any taste to find something they love!
2022: Long Islanders Voted Remember Yesteryears Best Antique Store!
Remember Yesteryears
901 Montauk Hwy., Oakdale
(631) 654-3052 – rememberyesteryears.com
Take a trip down memory lane at Remember Yesteryears in Oakdale. Here you will find everything from furniture and jewelry to military paraphernalia. There is no knowing what you will discover amongst these walls, but one thing is for sure, it is easy to get lost, so try to go there with a plan in mind. This store gives you the unique opportunity to shop collections from 120 dealers all under one roof. Remember Yesteryears is known for its knowledgeable and helpful staff, so it is no surprise why they have been selected as Long Island’s favorite antique shop. Next time you have a few hours to kill, stop by the store to see what treasures await you!
2021: Long Islanders Voted Remember Yesteryears Best Antique Store!
Remember Yesteryears
901 Montauk Hwy – Lighthouse Commons Shopping Center, Oakdale
(631) 654-3052 – rememberyesteryears.com
Take a trip down memory lane at Remember Yesteryears in Oakdale. Here you will find everything from furniture and jewelry to military paraphernalia. There is no knowing what you will discover amongst these walls, but one thing is for sure, it is easy to get lost so try to go there with a plan in mind. This store gives you the unique opportunity to shop collections from 120 dealers all under one roof. Remember Yesteryears is known for their knowledgeable and helpful staff, so it is no surprise why they have been selected as Long Island’s favorite antique shop. Next time you have a few hours to kill, stop by the store to see what treasures await you!
2020: Long Islanders Voted Rosie’s Vintage Best Antique Store!
Rosie’s Vintage
101 Woodbury Rd, Huntington
(631) 549-9100 – rosiesvintagestore.com
Dive in to the past when shopping at Rosie’s Vintage. Check out all the amazing treasures that this unique shop has to offer, and you’ll know why it was voted Best Antique Store for the 3rd year in a row. It’s the perfect place to score one-of-a-kind gifts for any occasion. And, what a great way to decorate your home! You never know what you’re going to discover here. Customers love Rosie’s ever-changing window displays and when you walk in, you’ll be greeted with new themed vintage displays every month, lovingly decorated by Rosie’s dealers showcasing their wonderful, eye-catching items. And don’t forget to browse Rosie’s Attic and online store for more yesteryear finds. Happy hunting!
2019: Long Islanders Voted Rosie’s Vintage Best Antique Store!
Rosie’s Vintage
101 Woodbury Road, Huntington
(631) 549-9100 – www.rosiesvintagestore.com
Who knew antiques could be so much fun? At Rosie’s Vintage in Huntington, fun is all around. On two floors! Other vintage stores have you searching for treasure buried among heaps of dusty junk. Rosie’s has a well-curated collection of mid-century home goods, furniture, clothing, vinyl, jewelry, and more. The staff knows their goods, and customers are encouraged to ask about an item’s history. Rosie’s is a fantastic place to find a gift guaranteed to surprise and delight. But you won’t leave without a few new pieces for your wardrobe or a light-up beer sign for your man cave!
2018: Long Islanders Voted Rosie’s Vintage Best Antique Store on Long Island!
Rosie’s Vintage
101 Woodbury Road
Huntington, NY 11743
(631) 549-9100 – www.rosiesvintagestore.com
Who knew antiques could be so much fun? At Rosie’s Vintage in Huntington, fun is all around. On two floors! Other vintage stores have you searching for treasure buried among heaps of dusty junk. Rosie’s has a well-curated collection of mid-century home goods, furniture, clothing, vinyl, jewelry, and more. The staff knows their goods, and customers are encouraged to ask about an item’s history. Rosie’s is a fantastic place to find a gift guaranteed to surprise and delight. But you won’t leave without a few new pieces for your wardrobe or a light-up beer sign for your man cave.
2017: Long Islanders Voted Hidden Treasures Found Best Antique Store on Long Island!
Hidden Treasures Found
277 Railroad Ave., Sayville. 631-335-0547. hiddentreasuresfound.org
This cozy and friendly store offers a unique collection of rustic, antique, vintage, and one-of-kind furniture, home décor and much more. They have a passion for finding and refinishing old pieces, making each unique in its own way. Their inventory is constantly changing, and they have new pieces daily, so you’ll always find something different! Stop in to find the perfect addition to your home, or bring in a piece of furniture for them to transform into a true work of antique art!
2016: Long Islanders Voted Deep End of the Sandbox Best Antique Store on Long Island!
Deep End of the Sandbox
650 Portion Rd., Lake Ronkonkoma. 631-676-3130. deependofthesandbox.com
Forever in a state of eternal timelessness, antiques possess the unique ability to transport us backwards to places and moments long since gone yet never quite forgotten. Whether a lamp, clock, piece of glassware or even a toy, these rare objects somehow embody the past while embracing the future, content in their multiplicity and preponderance. This repository of the extraordinary prides itself on being “not your grandma’s antique store.” Vinyl records, rock and roll memorabilia, vintage clothes, toys and everything else in between—Deep End of the Sandbox has it all!
2015: Long Islanders Voted Deep End of the Sandbox Best Antique Store on Long Island!
Deep End of the Sandbox
650 Portion Rd., Lake Ronkonkoma. 631-676-3130. deependofthesandbox.com
Whether you are in the market for a piece of vintage flair for your home or just love the thrill of the hunt, Deep End of the Sandbox was voted Best Antique Store on Long Island for good reason. From video games to furniture and home decor, this store has something for everybody. If nostalgia is your thing, go take a meander through this unique shop.
2014: Long Islanders Voted The Barkin’ Basement in Port Jefferson Best Antique Store on Long Island!
1. The Barkin’ Basement
116 E. Main St., Port Jefferson. 631-642-2275.
2. Country Junque
597 Middle Rd., Bayport. 631-472-2650. countryjunque.com
3. Antique Creations
1966 Broadhollow Rd., Farmingdale. 631-390-9661. obsessionantiques.com
2013: Long Islanders Voted Huntington Antiques Center in Cold Spring Harbor Best Antique Store on Long Island!
1. Huntington Antiques Center
129 Main St., Cold Spring Harbor. 631-549-0105. www.huntingtonantiquescenter.com
2. Somewhere In Time Antiques
162 Main St., Northport. 631-757-4148
3. Nadia Deeks
Glenwood Landing. (Happy hunting, patrons find it through word of mouth!)
2012: Long Islanders Voted Somewhere in Time Antiques in Northport Best Antique Store on Long Island!
1. Somewhere in Time Antiques
162 Main St., Northport. 631-757-4148
2. Yankee Peddler
1038 New York Ave., Huntington. 631-271-5817.
3. North Shore Antiques
451 N. Country Rd., Saint James. 631-584-2248. www.northshoreantiques.biz
2011: Long Islanders Voted Oakdale Antiques Plaza in Oakdale Best Antique Store on Long Island!
1. Oakdale Antiques Plaza
1236 Montauk Hwy., Oakdale. 631-567-3740.
2. Yankee Peddler Antiques
1038 New York Ave., Huntington Station. 631-271-5817.
3. Somewhere in Time Antiques
162 Main St., Northport. 631-757-4148.
2010: Long Islanders Voted Somewhere in Time Antiques of Northport the Best Antique Store on Long Island!
1. Somewhere in Time Antiques
162 Main St., Northport. 631-757-4148.
2. Browsery Antiques
449 Jericho Tpke., Huntington. 631-351-8893.
3. Nannyberry’s Antiques
32 MacArthur Ave., Huntington. 631-421-5491.
