There’s something about Long Islanders and their shopping malls. With every store imaginable all under one roof or bundled together, often with on-site restaurants, the mall is the optimal place to get all of your shopping done. Here are Long Island’s favorites!
2024: Long Island Voted Smith Haven Mall Best Mall!
Smith Haven Mall
313 Smith Haven Mall, Lake Grove
(631) 724-8066 – simon.com/mall/smith-haven-mall
A first time first place winner in this category, it shouldn’t be a surprise to many Middle Islanders and East Enders that Smith Haven Mall is who voters have chosen as the best mall! Managed by Simon Property Group, the complex boasts Macy’s, Dick’s Sporting Goods, and the eagerly anticipated Primark. Since its opening in 1969, the mall has evolved, undergoing a multimillion-dollar renovation in 2006–2007, introducing a lifestyle village and welcoming renowned brands like Apple, Cheesecake Factory, and L.L.Bean. Notable for its artistic history, the mall once housed works by Alexander Calder and Larry Rivers. As it adapts to changing retail landscapes, recent transformations include the departure of JCPenney, paving the way for Primark, and Sears’ shift to Stony Brook Advanced Medicine!
2023: Long Islanders Voted Roosevelt Field Mall Best Mall!
Roosevelt Field Mall
630 Old Country Rd., Garden City
(516) 742-8001 – simon.com/mall/roosevelt-field
There are so many awesome stores and things to do at Roosevelt Field Mall, you won’t know where to begin. With more than 200 retail stores and dining options, plus the AMC movie theater, Build-A-Bear Workshop, and Glow Golf indoor mini golf course, you can spend an entire day of fun at this Simon Mall. The food court has many options and plenty of seating, including outdoors. There are also ear piercing stands, pretzels stands, and much more. Roosevelt Field is always bustling with groups of friends, families, and couples getting some shopping done, grabbing a bite to eat, and enjoying a true mall experience. It’s no wonder Long Islanders voted it as the best mall!
2022: Long Islanders Voted Roosevelt Field Mall Best Mall!
Roosevelt Field Mall
630 Old Country Rd., Garden City
(516) 742-8000 – simon.com
There are so many awesome stores and things to do at Roosevelt Field Mall, you won’t know where to begin. With more than 200 retail stores and dining options, plus the AMC movie theater, Build-A-Bear Workshop, and Glow Golf indoor mini golf course, you can spend an entire day of fun at this Simon Mall. The food court has many options and plenty of seating, including outdoors. There are also ear piercing stands, pretzels stands, and much more. Roosevelt Field is always bustling with groups of friends, families, and couples getting some shopping done, grabbing a bite to eat, and enjoying a true mall experience. It’s no wonder Long Islanders voted it as the best mall!
2021: Long Islanders Voted Broadway Commons Best Mall!
Broadway Commons
358 N Broadway, Hicksville
(516) 939-0679 – atbroadwaycommons.com
Broadway Commons has a rich and significant history from Presidential candidate visits to history-making retail industry firsts. Originally an open-air shopping center named Mid-Island Shopping Plaza, Broadway Commons is conveniently located with central and easy access to the three major east and west express routes traversing Long Island. The frequented mall boasts some of the most popular brands in retail including H&M, Forever21, Victoria’s Secret / PINK, Bath & Body Works / White Barn, Old Navy, Express, Foot Locker, Yankee Candle, Francesca’s and the newly opened ROUND1 Bowling and Amusement. Broadway Commons is also cinema central with an in-center movie theater Broadway Multiplex Cinema, featuring state-of-the-art fully reclining luxury seating. The shopping destination’s anchor stores include Macy’s, Target, and IKEA.
2020: Long Islanders Voted Broadway Commons Best Mall!
Broadway Commons
358 N Broadway, Hicksville
(516) 939-0679 – atbroadwaycommons.com
Broadway Commons has a rich and significant history from Presidential candidate visits to history-making retail industry firsts. Originally an open-air shopping center named Mid-Island Shopping Plaza, Broadway Commons is conveniently located with central and easy access to the three major east and west express routes traversing Long Island. They boast some of the most popular brands in retail including H&M, Forever21, Victoria’s Secret / PINK, Bath & Body Works / White Barn, Old Navy, Express, Foot Locker, Yankee Candle, Francesca’s and the newly opened ROUND1 Bowling and Amusement. Broadway Commons is also cinema central with an in-center movie theater Broadway Multiplex Cinema, with state-of-the-art fully reclining luxury seating. The shopping destination’s anchor stores include Macy’s, Target, and IKEA.
2019: Long Islanders Voted Broadway Commons (Mall) – Hicksville Best Mall!
Broadway Commons (Mall) – Hicksville
358 N Broadway, Hicksville
(516) 939-0679 – www.atbroadwaycommons.com
Broadway Commons has a rich and significant history from Presidential candidate visits to history-making retail industry firsts. Originally an open-air shopping center named Mid-Island Shopping Plaza, Broadway Commons is conveniently located with central and easy access to the three major east and west express routes traversing Long Island. They boast some of the most popular brands in retail including H&M, Forever21, Victoria’s Secret / PINK, Bath & Body Works / White Barn, Old Navy, Express, Foot Locker, Yankee Candle, Francesca’s and the newly opened ROUND1 Bowling and Amusement. Broadway Commons is also cinema central with an in-center movie theater Broadway Multiplex Cinema, with state-of-the-art fully reclining luxury seating. The shopping destination’s anchor stores include Macy’s, Target, and IKEA.
2018: Long Islanders Voted Tanger Outlets at The Arches Best Mall on Long Island!
Tanger Outlets at The Arches
152 The Arches Circle
Deer Park NY 11729
631-667-0600. tangeroutlet.com/deerpark
With more than 100 stores, Tanger Outlets at the Arches is the one-stop shop for everything you need, and offers a shopping experience unlike any other. From clothes and shoes to accessories, makeup, and so much more, this extraordinary mall is also known for its fantastic prices! There’s also so much more to do than just shop. Tanger Outlets at The Arches is home to a multi-screen cinema, outdoor skating rink and plenty of restaurants, making it a great spot for family fun, too. With quality stores and countless merchandise at great prices, it’s no wonder why Long Islanders vote Tanger Outlets at the Arches to the top of this category, year after year!
2017: Long Islanders Voted Tanger Outlets at The Arches Best Mall on Long Island!
Tanger Outlets at The Arches
152 The Arches Circle, Deer Park. 631-667-0600. tangeroutlet.com/deerpark
With more than 100 stores, Tanger Outlets at the Arches is the one-stop shop for everything you need, and offers a shopping experience unlike any other. From clothes and shoes to accessories, makeup, and so much more, this extraordinary mall is also known for its fantastic prices! There’s also so much more to do than just shop. Tanger Outlets at The Arches is home to a multi-screen cinema, outdoor skating rink and plenty of restaurants, making it a great spot for family fun, too. With quality stores and countless merchandise at great prices, it’s no wonder why Long Islanders vote Tanger Outlets at the Arches to the top of this category, year after year!
National Winner: Smith Haven Mall
313 Smith Haven Mall, Lake Grove. 631-724-8066. simon.com/mall/smith-haven-mall
Smith Haven Mall is now home to more than 140 stores and offers something for everyone in the family. Perfect for everyday shopping or a back-to-school must-have spree, Smith Haven Mall provides shoppers the latest in clothing, household goods, electronics, and so much more. Worked up an appetite while perusing its many fantastic shops? Stop in at any one of the amazing restaurants that also call Smith Haven Mall home, such as Bahama Breeze, Bobby’s Burger Palace, or Bonefish Grill, among many others!
2016: Long Islanders Voted Tanger Outlets at The Arches Best Mall on Long Island!
Tanger Outlets at The Arches
152 The Arches Circle, Deer Park. 631-667-0600. tangeroutlet.com/deerpark 44444
For six years in a row Long Islanders have voted Tanger Outlets at The Arches The Best local shopping mall on Long Island, and it’s glaringly obvious why! This must-shop stop is home to more than 100 stores providing the finest clothing, shoes, handbags and accessories at the most competitive prices. Hungry while you peruse the countless wares and products? There’s a stellar lineup of restaurants and cafes onsite to fuel your shopping frenzy, along with a multiscreen cinema and even an outdoor skating rink for family fun in case you need a shopping break! With all this and so much more, Tanger Outlets at The Arches is not just a mall, but a shopping and entertainment destination all in one!
National Winner: Roosevelt Field Mall
630 Old Country Rd., Garden City. 516-742-8001. simon.com/mall/roosevelt-field 44444
Who doesn’t love a little retail therapy? Roosevelt Field is home to dozens of stores, shops and boutiques to satiate all of you and your family’s shopping needs and desires, from Macy’s and JCPenney to Ann Taylor, Kay Jewelers and so many more! This megamall also boasts a revamped food court, offering a wide selection of quality eats to help fuel that shopping crave!
2015: Long Islanders Voted Tanger Outlets at The Arches Best Mall on Long Island!
Tanger Outlets at The Arches
152 The Arches Circle, Deer Park. 631-667-0600. tangeroutlet.com/deerpark
Less of a shopping mall, and more of a destination, Tanger Outlets at The Arches offers shopping, dining and entertainment in a European-inspired shopping mecca. With top brands in clothing, shoes, accessories and home goods, you can browse through more than 90 brand name outlet shops and then enjoy dinner and a movie, or, if it’s chilly, even ice skating on their outdoor rink. The Arches also hosts a free concert series every summer with headline acts that draw large audiences from across Long Island. No wonder why Long Islanders voted it The Best!
National. Roosevelt Field Mall
630 Old Country Rd., Garden City. 516-742-8001. simon.com
Roosevelt Field Mall is so much more than your standard shopping mall. This is the ultimate in luxurious shops, from Bloomingdale’s, to Macy’s, to Nordstrom, and every single store you can imagine in between: J. Crew, The Gap, Dick’s Sporting Goods, and even a Lego Store, are but a few. Is there a gym? Check. Food court? Check-check. From department stores to specialty shops, a shopping excursion to Roosevelt Field Mall has endless possibilities, and savings, in store for you!
2014: Long Islanders Voted Tanger Outlets at The Arches in Deer Park Best Mall on Long Island!
1. Tanger Outlets at The Arches
152 The Arches Circle, Deer Park. 631-667-0600. tangeroutlet.com/deerpark
2. Tanger Outlets
200 Tanger Mall Dr., Riverhead. 631-369-2723. tangeroutlet.com/riverhead
3. The Americana
2060 Northern Blvd., Manhasset. 800-818-6767. americanamanhasset.com
National
Roosevelt Field Mall
630 Old Country Rd., Garden City. 516-742-8001. simon.com
2013: Long Islanders Voted Tanger Outlets at the Arches in Deer Park Best Mall on Long Island!
1. Tanger Outlets at The Arches
152 The Arches Circle, Deer Park. 631-667-0600. www.tangeroutlet.com/deerpark
2. Tanger Outlets
1770 W. Main St., Riverhead. 631-369-2732. www.tangeroutlet.com/riverhead
3. The Americana
2060 Northern Blvd., Manhasset. 516-627-2277. www.americanamanhasset.com
National
Roosevelt Field Mall
630 Old Country Rd., Garden City. 516-742 8000. www.simon.com/mall/roosevelt-field
2012: Long Islanders Voted Tanger Outlets at the Arches in Deer Park Best Mall on Long Island!
1. Tanger Outlets at the Arches Deer Park
152 The Arches Circle, Deer Park. 631-242-0239. www.tangeroutlet.com/deerpark
2. The Americana
2060 Northern Blvd., Manhasset. 516-627-2277. www.americanamanhasset.com
3. Wheatley Plaza
Glen Cove Road at Northern Boulevard. 888-627-2250. www.wheatleyplaza.com
National
Roosevelt Field Mall
630 Old Country Rd., Garden City. 631-724-1433
2011: Long Islanders Voted Tanger Outlets- The Arches At Deer Park Best Mall on Long Island!
1. Tanger Outlets-The Arches At Deer Park
152 The Arches Circle, Deer Park. 631-667-0600. www.tangeroutlet.com/deerpark
2. The Americana
2060 Northern Blvd., Manhasset. 516-627-2277. www.americanamanhasset.com
3. Bellport Outlets
10 Farber Dr., Bellport. 631-286-3872. www.bellportoutlets.net
National
Roosevelt Field Mall
630 Old Country Rd., Garden City. 516-742-8000. www.simon.com
2010: Long Islanders Voted The Americana in Manhasset the Best Mall on Long Island!
1. The Americana
2060 Northern Blvd., Manhasset. 516-627-2277. www.americanamanhasset.com
2. Roosevelt Field Mall
630 Old Country Rd., Garden City. 516-742-8000. www.rooseveltfield.com
3. Walt Whitman Mall
160 Walt Whitman Rd., Huntington. 631-271-1741. www.simon.com
National
Smith Haven Mall
313 Smith Haven Mall, Lake Grove. 631-724-1433. www.simon.com
