Being that Long Island is a hotspot for fishing and other seafood, it’s no wonder there are so many restaurants dedicated to serving up crustaceans and fish to eat. From appetizers and entrees, to lunch specials and more, Long Island is home to some of the best seafood restaurants on the East Coast. And luckily for you, the best is only a short drive away. Stop for a bite at the Best Seafood Restaurant on Long Island on the way home from the beach during the summer, or when your tastebuds are craving something fishy.
2024: Long Island Voted Neraki Greek Mediterranean Best Seafood Restaurant!
Neraki Greek Mediterranean
273 Main St, Huntington
(631) 385-3474 – neraki.com
Discover the enchanting flavors of the Mediterranean at Neraki Greek Mediterranean, a beloved Huntington gem for 13 years. This local, family-owned restaurant passionately crafts traditional Greek cuisine using age-old recipes passed down through generations. Dive into a culinary journey where the owner handpicks fresh fish, meat, and vegetables daily from Hunts Point Markets, ensuring unparalleled quality. With purveyors in Greece, Neraki sources the finest olive oil, feta, and more for an authentic taste of the Mediterranean. Immerse yourself in the warmth of a kitchen where passion meets tradition, savoring health-conscious, handpicked ingredients. Join us at Neraki for an unforgettable dining experience, where every meal feels like a cherished family gathering.Reserve your table and embark on a gastronomic voyage to Greece!
2023: Long Islanders Voted Anchor Down Seafood Bar and Grill Best Seafood Restaurant!
Anchor Down Seafood Bar and Grill
1960 Bayberry Ave., Merrick
(516) 544-4334 – anchordownny.com
When Long Islanders want seafood, they have many options to choose from, of course. This year, they have selected Anchor Down Seafood Bar and Grill as Best Seafood Restaurant on Long Island! The restaurant serves upscale seafood dishes, including horseradish crusted salmon, in a casual setting. The experienced chef and owner has nearly 25 years of experience in the hospitality sector, with stints at restaurants including Brasserie in Manhattan and the now-defunct Legal Seafoods in Garden City. One online reviewer noted his party “loved our maiden visit on a Saturday night” and “we loved every dish we ordered.” So if you’re in the mood for seafood, be sure to make reservations at Anchor Down!
2022: Long Islanders Voted Anchor Down Seafood Bar and Grill Best Seafood Restaurant!
Anchor Down Seafood Bar and Grill
1960 Bayberry Ave., Merrick
(516) 544-4334 – anchordownny.com
Long Island has no shortage of great seafood restaurants, but one bayside joint in Merrick really makes a splash. Anchor Down Seafood Bar & Grill serves up some of the very best seafood on the island in a fun, comfortable atmosphere. Since it first opened in 2014, customers have raved over its classic fish and chips, lobster bisque, lobster pot pie, shrimp, and po’boy sandwiches. Anchor Down’s casual dinner menu will win over even the pickiest of fish eaters and quickly become a favorite seafood dining experience for the whole family. Plus, don’t miss out on the restaurant’s regular lobster specials and rotating oyster selections. You’ll be glad you got your seafood fix at Anchor Down!
2021: Long Islanders Voted Anchor Down Seafood Bar and Grill Best Seafood Restaurant!
Anchor Down Seafood Bar and Grill
1960 Bayberry Ave, Merrick
(516) 544-4334 – anchordownny.com
Anchor Down Seafood Bar and Grill has been serving some of the best local seafood on the island in a comfortable and casual atmosphere since 2014. Customers rave over its classic fish and chips, lobster bisque, shrimp and po’boy sandwiches and delight in Anchor Down’s more dynamic dishes such as the lobster pot pie—consisting of root vegetables, sherry bechamel and puff pastry. Anchor Down’s seafood menu is sure to satisfy the pickiest of fish eaters and even win over carnivores who are normally set on ordering a burger or steak!
2020: Long Islanders Voted Anchor Down Seafood Bar and Grill Best Seafood Restaurant!
Anchor Down Seafood Bar and Grill
1960 Bayberry Ave, Merrick
(516) 544-4334 – anchordownny.com
Anchor Down Seafood Bar and Grill has been serving some of the best local seafood on the island in a comfortable and casual atmosphere since 2014. Customers rave over their classic fish and chips, lobster bisque, shrimp and po’boy sandwiches and enjoy Anchor Down’s more dynamic dishes such as the lobster pot pie consisting of root vegetables, sherry bechamel and puff pastry. Anchor Down’s seafood menu is sure to satisfy the pickiest of fish eaters and even win over carnivores who are normally set on ordering a burger or steak!
2019: Long Islanders Voted Neraki Greek Mediterranean Best Seafood Restaurant!
Neraki Greek Mediterranean
273 Main St., Huntington
(631) 385-3474 – www.neraki.com
When it comes to amazing, fresh seafood dishes, there’s no place better than Neraki Greek Mediterranean Grill. A night out deserves a drink to celebrate, and this restaurant has the perfect selection of beer and wine to go with your meal. Youngsters don’t need to sit out a trip to this restaurant; its super family-friendly and perfect for little diners and their folks. No time to sit down? No worries! This restaurant offers a takeout option so you can grab your food on the go.
2018: Long Islanders Voted Anchor Down Bar and Grill Best Seafood Restaurant on Long Island!
Anchor Down Bar and Grill
1960 Bayberry Ave.
Merrick NY 11566
516-544-4334. anchordownny.com
If you want to dine at the Best Seafood Restaurant on Long Island, set sail for Anchor Down Seafood Bar and Grill in South Merrick, which has won the voters’ acclaim in this hotly contested category. Getting this distinction is a great catch for owner and chef, Stephen Rosenbluth, who’s been at the helm of many a kitchen before finding safe harbor here. Customers are hooked on the oyster selection, the mussels in Thai coconut curry, the fried calamari and shrimp sautéed in hot peppers, basil and marinara sauce, and they go over the deep end for the Garlic Panko Crusted Sole simmered in white wine. Anchors away, indeed!
2017: Long Islanders Voted Anchor Down Bar and Grill Best Seafood Restaurant on Long Island
Anchor Down Bar and Grill 1960 Bayberry Ave., Merrick. 516-544-4334. anchordownny.com If you want to dine at the Best Seafood Restaurant on Long Island, set sail for Anchor Down Seafood Bar and Grill in South Merrick, which has won the voters’ acclaim in this hotly contested category. Getting this distinction is a great catch for owner and chef, Stephen Rosenbluth, who’s been at the helm of many a kitchen before finding safe harbor here. Customers are hooked on the oyster selection, the mussels in Thai coconut curry, the fried calamari and shrimp sautéed in hot peppers, basil and marinara sauce, and they go over the deep end for the Garlic Panko Crusted Sole simmered in white wine. Anchors away, indeed!
2016: Long Islanders Voted Anchor Down Seafood Bar and Grill Best Seafood Restaurant on Long Island
Anchor Down Bar and Grill 1960 Bayberry Ave., Merrick. 516-544-4334. anchordownny.com If you want The Best seafood on Long Island, then set sail for Anchor Down Seafood Bar and Grill in South Merrick, which has won the voters’ acclaim in this hotly contested category. Getting this distinction is a great catch for owner and chef, Stephen Rosenbluth, who’s been at the helm of many a kitchen before finding safe harbor here. Customers are hooked on the oyster selection, the mussels in Thai coconut curry, the fried calamari and shrimp sautéed in hot peppers, basil and marinara sauce, and they go over the deep end for the Garlic Panko Crusted Sole simmered in white wine. Anchors away, indeed!
2015: Long Islanders Voted Vincent’s Clam Bar Best Seafood Restaurant on Long Island!
Vincent’s Clam Bar 179 Old Country Rd., Carle Place. 516-742-4577. vincentsclambar.com Long Islanders sure love their Vincent’s Clam Bar! This best seafood restaurant on Long Island is known for its clams, but don’t think it stops there. Besides the oreganata and baked clam specialties, try the mussels bianco, the calamari arrabiata (Italian for “angry sauce”) and truly special “Lobster Kiss.”
2014: Long Islanders Voted Rachel’s Waterside Grill in Freeport Best Seafood on Long Island!
1. Rachel’s Waterside Grill 281 Woodcleft Ave., Freeport. 516-546-0050. rachelswatersidegrill.com Long Island boasts a huge assortment of seafood restaurants, but according to Bethpage Best of LI voters, one consistently tops the rest. As one of the crown jewels of Freeport’s Nautical Mile, Rachel’s Waterside Grill is a great catch—hook, line and sinker. Whether pan-seared, blackened or grilled, the seafood at Rachel’s is as fresh and tasty as it gets. Newly renovated after Superstorm Sandy, Rachel’s is back and better than ever! 2. Vincent’s Clam Bar 179 Old Country Rd., Carle Place. 516-742-4577. vincentsclambar.com 3. H2O Seafood Grill 215 W. Main St., Smithtown. 631-361-6463. h2oseafoodgrill.com
2013: Long Islanders Voted Rachel’s Waterside Grill in Freeport Best Seafood Restaurant on Long Island!
1. Rachel’s Waterside Grill 281 Woodcleft Ave., Freeport. 516-546-0050. www.rachelswatersidegrill.com 2. Vincent’s Clam Bar 179 Old Country Rd., Carle Place. 516-742-4577. www.vincentsclambar.com 3. Popei’s Clam Bar 384 N. Wantagh Ave., Bethpage. 516-822-9169. www.popeisbethpage.com
2012: Long Islanders Voted Rachel’s Waterside Grill in Freeport Best Seafood Restaurant on Long Island!
1. Rachel’s Waterside Grill 281 Woodcleft Ave., Freeport. 516-546-0050. www.rachelswatersidegrill.com 2. Popei’s Clam Bar 384 N. Wantagh Ave., Bethpage. 516-822-9169. www.popeisbethpage.com 3. H2O Seafood Grill 215 W. Main St., Smithtown. 631-361-6464. www.h2oseafoodgrill.com
2011: Long Islanders Voted Rachel’s Waterside Grill in Freeport Best Seafood Restaurant on Long Island!
1. Rachel’s Waterside Grill 281 Woodcleft Ave., Freeport. 516-546-0050. www.rachelswatersidegrill.com 2. Riverbay Seafood Bar & Grill 700 Willis Ave., Williston Park. 516-742-9191. www.riverbayrestaurant.com 3. Bigelow’s 79 N. Long Beach Rd., Rockville Centre. 516-678-3878. www.bigelows-rvc.com
2010: Long Islanders Voted Riverbay Seafood Bar & Grill Best Seafood on Long Island!
1. Riverbay Seafood Bar & Grill 700 Willis Ave. Williston Park 516-742-9191 www.riverbayrestaraunt.com 2. H2O Seafood Grill 215 W. Main St., Smithtown. 631-361-6464. www.h2oseafoodgrill.com 3. Cool Fish 6800 Jericho Tpke., Syosset. 516-921-3250. www.tomschaudel.com National – Legal Seafood, Multiple locations. www.legalseafoods.com
