What’s old is new again when shopping for classic styles. Look no further than Long Island’s best vintage shops to find one of a kind styles that you won’t find at the mall.
2024: Long Island Voted Paper Doll Vintage Boutique Best Vintage Clothing Store!
Paper Doll Vintage Boutique
23 Main St, Sayville
(631) 319-1919 – shoppaperdoll.com
Paper Doll Vintage Boutique has marks a milestone tenth win as Long Island’s Best Vintage Clothing Store. The unique emporium showcases an extensive array of vintage garments and accessories, spanning eras from the 1900s to the Y2K era. Dominique Maciejk’s love for collecting vintage, ignited during her youth while exploring garage sales and thrift stores with her mother, has blossomed into a thriving business. The boutique has since evolved to include pin-up reproductions, upcycled accessories, and locally crafted art. Furthermore, it fosters a sense of community by providing a platform for local designers, artists, and fashion enthusiasts through monthly art and fashion shows, classes, and events. Explore their website to peruse the exquisite selections.
2023: Long Islanders Voted Paper Doll Vintage Boutique Best Vintage Clothing Store!
Paper Doll Vintage Boutique
23 Main St, Sayville
(631) 319-1919 – shoppaperdoll.com
Paper Doll Vintage Boutique celebrates its ninth win as Long Island’s Best Vintage Clothing Store. The eclectic shop offers a rich collection of vintage clothing and accessories spanning time from the 1900s to the Y2K era. Dominique Maciejk began her passion for collecting vintage at a young age, when she went to garage sales and thrifting stores with her mom. Her store has expanded, now offering pin-up reproductions, upcycled accessories, and local art. Additionally, it offers community to local designers, artists, and fashion lovers with monthly art and fashion shows, classes, and events. Check out their website to browse all of their beautiful selections or purchase a Vintage and Retro Mystery Box, where you can select a budget in return for a bundle of vintage and retro items selected with thought and care.
2022: Long Islanders Voted Paper Doll Vintage Boutique Best Vintage Clothing Store!
Paper Doll Vintage Boutique
23 Main St, Sayville
(631) 319-1919 – facebook.com/PaperDollVintageBoutique
Paper Doll Vintage Boutique is a long-time Long Island favorite, so it is no surprise that it has once again been selected as the top vintage clothing store. With employees that are able to pay special attention to customers’ needs and unbeatable service, Paper Doll is a place worth visiting. The popular vintage shop will have people asking you where you got your dress the moment you step into the party! With beautiful collections and pieces that will make you the center of attention and photographs that will make your friends jealous, Paper Doll Vintage Boutique should be on your emergency contact list!
2021: Long Islanders Voted Carrie’s Closet Best Vintage Clothing Store!
Carrie’s Closet
49 S Mall, Plainview
(516) 586-6533 – shopcarries.com
Carrie’s Closet is not your typical Long Island boutique. Each one of the pieces the store sells are carefully selected by the Chief BOHO Officer and purchased in limited quantities. After shopping here, there is no way you wont get question after question about where you shop thanks to the boutique uniqueness as well as their boho-chic style. From the moment a customer walks into the store, they receive personalized services from one of the store’s expert employees. This boutique hopes to make everyone feel at home and comfortable when shopping. Once you leave here you will become a true Instagram queen with their vintage pieces that will have everything begging for your secret for the best vintage clothing!
2020: Long Islanders Voted Paper Doll Vintage Boutique – Sayville Best Vintage Clothing Store!
Paper Doll Vintage Boutique – Sayville
23 Main St, Sayville
(631) 319-1919 – shoppaperdoll.com
Paper Doll Vintage Boutique is a long-time Long Island favorite, so it is no surprise that they have once again been selected as the top vintage clothing store. With employees that are able to pay special attention to customers’ needs and unbeatable service, Paper Doll is a place worth visiting. The popular vintage shop will have people asking you where you got your dress the moment you step into the party! With beautiful collections and pieces that will make you the center of attention, and photographs that will make your friends jealous, Paper Doll Vintage Boutique should be on your emergency contact list!
2019: Long Islanders Voted Paper Doll Vintage Boutique Best Vintage Clothing Store!
Paper Doll Vintage Boutique
23 Main St., Sayville
(631) 319-1919 – www.facebook.com/PaperDollVintageBoutique
Want to channel your inner Audrey Hepburn? Admire the style of Raquel Welch? Well, with the help of Paper Doll Vintage Boutique, you won’t have to look very far for inspiration—just Sayville! This vintage clothing store, who has won this category for five years in a row, offers an assortment of retro merchandise, from dresses and skirts to coats and jackets. You will also fall in love with the 1970s-inspired handbags and 1940s-inspired hats, making you feel as if you just traveled back in time. And that’s not all. You can even shop online through their Etsy website, allowing you to browse through their new, “old” looks whenever and wherever you want!
2018: Long Islanders Voted Paper Doll Vintage Boutique Best Vintage Clothing Store on Long Island
Paper Doll Vintage Boutique
23 Main St., Sayville. 631-319-1919. facebook.com/PaperDollVintageBoutique/
Want to channel your inner Audrey Hepburn? Admire the style of Raquel Welch? Well, with the help of Paper Doll Vintage Boutique, you won’t have to look very far for inspiration—just Sayville! This vintage clothing store offers an assortment of retro merchandise, from dresses and skirts to coats and jackets. You will also fall in love with the 1970s-inspired handbags and 1940s-inspired hats, making you feel as if you just traveled back in time. And that’s not all. You can even shop online through their Etsy website, allowing you to browse through their new, “old” looks whenever and wherever you want!
2017: Long Islanders Voted Paper Doll Vintage Boutique Best Vintage Clothing Store on Long Island
Paper Doll Vintage Boutique
23 Main St., Sayville. 631-319-1919. facebook.com/PaperDollVintageBoutique/
Want to channel your inner Audrey Hepburn? Admire the style of Raquel Welch? Well, with the help of Paper Doll Vintage Boutique, you won’t have to look very far for inspiration—just Sayville! This vintage clothing store, who has won this category for five years in a row, offers an assortment of retro merchandise, from dresses and skirts to coats and jackets. You will also fall in love with the 1970s-inspired handbags and 1940s-inspired hats, making you feel as if you just traveled back in time. And that’s not all. You can even shop online through their Etsy website, allowing you to browse through their new, “old” looks whenever and wherever you want!
2016: Long Islanders Voted Paper Doll Vintage Boutique Best Vintage Clothing Store on Long Island
Paper Doll Vintage Boutique
23 Main St., Sayville. 631-319-1919. shoppaperdollvintage.com
Are you drawn to the styles of the great Bettie Page, Veronica Lake or Rita Hayworth? Nestled in Long Island’s Sayville is a place so whimsical, so colorful, and so full of unique pieces from the past that if vintage pin-up is your style, you’ll spend hours living among its epic wardrobe history. At Paper Doll Vintage Boutique you’ll be transported to eras of style that many only dream about, but a lucky (in the know) few still wear. Pulling off vintage is truly an art, and Paper Doll knows this. With a stylistically educated staff in both clothing and beauty, Paper Doll offers vintage and pin-up makeup and hair tutorials to really set you up with the most unique style on the Island. And it doesn’t stop there. Paper Doll knows that true vintage lovers have a knack for art, and so they share their support by showcasing customers’ and local artists’ pieces at multiple shows throughout the year. These are just some of the reasons why Paper Doll Vintage Boutique has been crowned Long Island’s best vintage clothing store, year after year!
2015: Long Islanders Voted Paper Doll Vintage Boutique Best Vintage Clothing Store on Long Island!
Paper Doll Vintage Boutique
23 Main St., Sayville. 631-319-1919. shoppaperdollvintage.com
The mall might not be your thing, nor the “latest” trends and styles. You might have a unique style that’s all your own, drawn from the designs and designers of the past. If this sounds like you, a trip to Paper Doll Vintage might be a slice of heaven. Each vintage piece is inspected to be in top-quality condition. The friendly—and stylish—staff will help you create a head-to-toe look that will bring that style to life!
2014: Long Islanders Voted Paper Doll Vintage Boutique in Sayville Best Vintage Clothing Store on Long Island!
1. Paper Doll Vintage Boutique
23 Main St., Sayville. 631-319-1919. shoppaperdollvintage.com
The mall might not be your thing. You might not be into the latest styles. You might have an amazing style of your own, drawn from the designs of the past. You might be one of a kind. If you are, you will find Paper Doll Vintage to be a little slice of heaven. Each vintage piece is inspected to be in top-quality condition. The friendly—and stylish—staff will help you create a head-to-toe look that will make you uniquely stylish.
2. Lotus Vintage
12 W. Carver St., Huntington. 631-470-7795. lotusvintage.com
3. Utopia
3 Newbridge Rd., Hicksville. 516-935-6680. incensewarehouse.com
NATIONAL
Goodwill Stores. Multiple Locations. 800-GOODWILL. goodwill.org
2013: Long Islanders Voted Paper Doll Vintage Boutique in Sayville Best Vintage Clothing Store on Long Island!
1. Paper Doll Vintage Boutique
23 N. Main St., Sayville. 631-319-1919. www.facebook.com/paperdollvintageboutique
2. Salvage Chic Boutique
156 E. Park Ave., Long Beach. www.salvagechicboutique.com
3. Lotus Vintage
12 W. Carver St., Huntington. 631-470-7795
2012: Long Islanders Voted Ooh La La in Long Beach Best Vintage Clothing Store on Long Island!
1. Ooh La La
Multiple locations. 134 E. Park Ave., Long Beach. 516-431-4070. www.oohlalaboutiques.com
2. Utopia
3 Newbridge Rd., Hicksville. 516-935-6680. www.facebook.com/shoputopia
3. Free People
Roosevelt Field Mall, Garden City. 516-873-7380. www.freepeople.com
2011: Long Islanders Voted The Denim Rehab in North Massapequa the Best Vintage Clothing Store on Long Island!
1. The Denim Rehab
954 Broadway, North Massapequa. 516-541-2250. www.thedenimrehab.com
2. Utopia
3 Newbridge Rd., Hicksville. 516-935-6680. www.shoputopia.com
3. Goodwill Industries
1500 Middle Country Rd., Centereach. 631-698-0860. www.goodwillny.org